Stab Podcast: Did The Right Surfer Win At Barra? - Stab Mag

Stab Podcast: Did The Right Surfer Win At Barra?

Let’s talk about dynamicism vs. seamless repetition.

Words by Michael Ciaramella

Late last week, Australian Jack Robinson made history by winning his first CT event and re-qualifying for the 2022 Tour in the process. Right behind Jack was Brazil’s Devid Silva, the man Kelly Slater claims to have the best backhand on tour and who some people believe should have won the final.

Jack finished the heat two-hundredths of a point ahead of David, which is the statistical equivalent of fuck all. What’s interesting is that, despite the proximity of their totals, Jack and Deivid couldn’t have surfed their waves more differently.

Jack’s waves both started with a barrel, featured an air at some point, and had several humdrum turns in between. Deivid’s waves were significantly less dynamic but featured series of fast, connected turns that Jack clearly lacked. So it wasn’t so much a decision of who surfed better (as their surfing was apples and oranges), but rather what the judges wanted to see more.

By putting Jack ahead, the judges declared that dynamicism trumps seamless repetition, which for the sake of surfing’s progression, is the correct decision. But as Stace G says in this week’s episode of the Stab CUSP, “If that was a round one heat, I think Deivid would have won.”

Watch the heat below, then tune in to our Mexico episode above.


Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up


Most Recent

Meet Liv Stone, The Pennsylvania-Born Para Surf World Champion

It’s feel-good time!

Nov 27, 2021

We’re Having Trouble Picking Snapt4’s ‘Best Barrel’ and Monster ‘Maneuver’

Here are the official nominees. Help us out.

Nov 27, 2021

Stab Podcast: Will Peninsula Boy Kelly Slater Spin His Way To Glory At Haleiwa?

Let's hope nobody leaves a menacing note on his car.

Nov 26, 2021


Watch: Lucas Godfrey Is The Most Barreled Man Of The Summer

Puerto Escondido has rarely been surfed like this.

Nov 26, 2021

Watch: Final Episode Of Stab Highway Presented By Monster Energy

It's time to go home.

Nov 26, 2021


Every Once In A While, A Genuine Super-Talent Rears His Pretty Little Head

Bronson Meydi might be that kid.

Nov 25, 2021

Haydenshapes Is Doing A Flash Sale On Their Most Precious Blood Diamonds

7 limited edition ‘altered’ surfboards, discounts, and an exclusive art series rollout across stock models.

Nov 25, 2021

Who’s Going To Make The CT This Year?

Haleiwa, prophesied.

Nov 24, 2021

Let’s Get You A Free Private Session At URBNSURF

We're treating six Stab Premium members to a free surf and tickets to the URBNSURF…

Nov 24, 2021


Nic Von Rupp Just Tamed A Giant Nazaré Tube By Hand (No Ski)

Yes, this is a paddle-in.

Nov 23, 2021


Watch: The Best ‘Shit Waves’ We’ve Seen With Dane Reynolds And Co.

Everything is relative.

Nov 23, 2021

Luca Padua Is A Badass Motherfucker

Meet the 19-year old big-wave prodigy being mentored by Laird Hamilton.

Nov 23, 2021

“My Wife Probably Wouldn’t Have Been Bitten By A Pit Viper If We Lived On A Charter Boat”

A land-based surf camp owner explains how his life and business differ from a boat-based…

Nov 23, 2021


Jordy And J-Bay Go Together Like Old Bay And Popcorn

Grab a fistful and inhale.

Nov 22, 2021

Opinion: In The Age Of The Vlog, It’s Getting Harder To Find Good Surf Films

Surfing and storytelling are two entirely different skillsets.

Nov 22, 2021


Cole Houshmand Gets Crapped On By A Bird, Proceeds To Score Out Of His Mind

Smooth, surgical lines from the San Clemente gentleman in 'Good Luck'.

Nov 22, 2021


Erin Brooks Is A Rare Type Of Talent — We Can’t Stop Watching

Watch the Ladybird air-drop into Kandui caverns with a grin on her face.

Nov 22, 2021

Watch: Harry Bryant’s Feary Sydney Harbour Bridge Swim

One for the history books.

Nov 22, 2021