Watch: Snapper Favorite Mateus Herdy Loses Fin In Mid-Air - Stab Mag
Hate to see it.

Watch: Snapper Favorite Mateus Herdy Loses Fin In Mid-Air

You have to see this to believe it.

news // May 7, 2022
Words by Michael Ciaramella
Reading Time: 2 minutes

Based on pre-event form, Mateus Herdy was a favorite going into the Snapper CS event.

With an aerial success rate above 50% and finely-tuned JS boards underfoot, it seemed only a gruesome injury or 29-minute flat spell could keep the Brazilian away from finals day.

Alas, it was actually a fin.

Needing a low-seven to advance from his Round 2 heat, Mateus took off on a mid-sized runner and started pumping down the line. After a few projection floats, the Brazilian waited for the inside double-up to take shape, where he then hucked a Crisco-clean air rev on the first available section. Poetry.

After greasing the air, Mateus shifted his feet back into position for the next available section, which was begging for a forehand wrap. Rotating his hips and shoulders like he’s done thousands of times before, Mateus squared up with the section but his board behaved…unusually. Rather than gripping the wall with its heelside rail, the JS slid and sunk simultaneously, causing its rider to tip over the toeside rail and forfeit the rest of the ride.

Mateus received a 5.77 for his efforts. He never caught another wave.

Hit play. It’s pre-timed for your convenience.

So what happened here?

Upon closer review, it’s apparent that Mateus’s fall (and subsequent heat loss) were not due to user error, but rather equipment malfunction. If you watch the slow-motion replay above, you can clearly see the Brazilian’s center fin flying out while he’s in the middle of his air. Mateus manages to land the air in spite of this, but his next turn attempt is doomed from the start.

As anyone who’s taken the center fin out of their HP shorty knows, these boards simply are not meant to function as a twin fin. And even if Mateus was talented enough to make his JS work with just side bites (spoiler alert: he probably is), the fact that it happened mid-wave meant Mateus had no idea that his next bottom turn would react significantly different from his last, leaving him at a severe disadvantage.

Had Mateus completed a solid turn on the next section and surfed the wave to its conclusion, there’s no doubt in my mind that he would have gotten the required score.

Equipment malfunctions happen in every sport, and to every brand, but you hate to see their effects so blatantly impact an outcome.


Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up


Most Recent

“I Don’t Want To Say Schizophrenic But We Saw A Plethora Of Different Scenarios To The Wave Out Here”

Rio Waida, Teresa Bonvalot, Harrison Roach & Honolua Bloomfield win Manly.

May 24, 2022

The Former Top 5 Surfer Carrying The Next Big Surfer-Owned Beer Company On His Back 

What would you do if Matt Hoy showed up to deliver you beer?

May 23, 2022

CT Told To Elect Single Surfers Rep From Shortlist Of Four Tasked With Reviewing All Future WSL Policy Changes Onboard ‘Special Committee’

Take your pick: Tyler Wright, Jadson Andre, Tatiana Weston-Webb or Griffin Colapinto.

May 23, 2022

What Happened To The Best Surf Film Ever Made?

Captain Martin Daly demystifies the conspiracies surrounding his and Michael Oblowitz's Surfer Poll-winning "Sea of…

May 23, 2022

Stab Podcast: The Dane Reynolds Interview

Carrying the torch for authentic creativity, storytelling, performance and passion.

May 23, 2022

Waves To Be Lost And Waves To Be Found 

A silver lining to the problem of sea level rise.

May 22, 2022

California University Professors Claim (Most) Wetsuits Are Being Made Wrong In Peppery Peer-Reviewed Study

“What the surf industry is marketing is not being driven by science.”

May 22, 2022

Why G-Land’s CT Comeback Is Ten Years Late

A tale of geopolitics, swooshes in Surf City, and hurricanes in the urban jungle.

May 21, 2022

An Interview With Transgender Longboarding Champion Sasha Jane Lowerson

"In longboarding, the girls are so much better than the guys, and that's just a…

May 21, 2022


The Best Surfing I’ve Ever Seen: Blake Kueny

Insight from a man who spent good years pointing a camera in John John’s general…

May 20, 2022

First Transgender Woman To Compete In Surfing Wins WA Longboard Event

History has been written

May 20, 2022

WSL Now Sponsored By Ladder

A seemingly odd partnership that actually makes perfect sense.

May 19, 2022

Now Unlocked: Former’s New Film, ‘System Is Yours’

17-minutes of pleasure from Dane Reynolds, Craig Anderson, Droid, Ben Howard and Kaito Ohashi.

May 19, 2022


Bobby Martinez Isn’t Going To Sweet Talk You Into The Bobby Quad

"It kept me in the water on shitty little gutless days. Take that how you…

May 19, 2022

Dane Reynolds On “The Best Thing In The World,” Business, Fin Splay, The WSL, Modern Surf Culture And More

The Stab Interview: Sealtooth.

May 18, 2022


Chapter11 Drops Three New Edits

Clean waves, cleaner rail work, and A-frame goodness.  

May 18, 2022


The First Time JJF Visited The GOAT Ranch

When wavepools mesmerized.

May 18, 2022

A Small Fat Nothing Burger

The Snapper CS will be a tough act to follow for Manly. Here’s why.

May 18, 2022