Stab Magazine | The Journalist And The Great White Shark

The Journalist And The Great White Shark

Veteran journalist Fred Pawle gives us the lowdown on his recent North Coast shark investigation for The Australian national newspaper.

Words by stab

Yesterday (Monday), veteran journalist from The Australian national newspaper, Fred Pawle, started publishing his six-part series about the shark problem on the NSW North Coast surf region (an area that encompasses Ballina, Lennox Head and Byron Bay). As you’re probably aware, that 70km stretch of coast has become one of the world capitals for shark attacks. In the past three years, there have been at least 11 attacks, including two fatalities. Fred was also the former feature writer for Stab (during which period his profile of West Australian gay surfer, Matt Branson was nominated for a Walkley journalism award). He has also been a surfer for 40 years. Here, in an exclusive for Stab readers, he outlines some of the key takeaways from his investigation.

Stab: What were the big takeaways from your investigation into the shark situation on the NSW North Coast?
Fred Pawle: The locals are sick to death of being ignored. They have been putting up with frequent attacks and almost daily sightings for three years, and all they want is to go surfing. The ones who still surf have developed their own ways of dealing with the fear. Some of them are fatalistic, some are superstitious, some are just plain determined not to let a bunch of politicians and scientists stop them from surfing. Anybody who hasn’t developed resilience to the fear has simply given up surfing, which is tragic. Also, the region has a geopolitical divide. Byron is full of trippy conservationists who oppose nets and resent any attempt by mankind to influence or control the natural environment; Ballina has more families who just want their kids to be safe while playing in the ocean. Also, neither side is ever going to persuade the other. This debate will never be resolved.

ScaleWidthWyIxMjAwIl0 Evans Head Panoramic Main

What was your experience with that area prior to doing this? Totally chilled. I’ve always absolutely loved that stretch of coast. One of my favourite beaches in Australia is Whites, behind Broken Head. It’s totally idyllic. However, I’d never surf it now because the only way out is a long walk through the bush. Even a minor attack there could easily be fatal, given that you’d lose so much blood before you got to hospital.

What did you find most surprising in the process? How spooky the beaches at Ballina are. I was expecting them to be deserted, but I didn’t realise how much that would creep me out. You walk along the sand, and all you can think about is what might be swimming past just 100m away. You see fun, empty waves, and it gives you chills.

How are local people and business owners getting on through all this? The towns still look prosperous enough, but some businesses are suffering a lot. Ask me the same question in 10 years, after a generation of kids have grown up without surfing as their main distraction.

ballina lighthouse beach 3 900x600

Who seemed least concerned out of the people you spoke to – surfers, families, business owners, fishermen, authorities? Conservationists. They will never concede that human life is more important than a turtle’s.

Who seemed most concerned? Le-Ba president Don Munro. That guy has fought the good fight for years. He has the determination of a bulldog and the patience of a saint.

Having finished the investigation, do you have an opinion on what is the most rational solution? I’m still researching some of the finer details, but with a bit of luck I’ll have some major conclusions soon. Stay tuned!

Follow Fred’s North Coast Shark series here.


Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up


Most Recent

Post-career blues: mental illness, substance abuse and World Tour surfing.

Jed Smith explores the vortex of drugs, decadence and poor mental health plaguing pro surfing's…


A Game Of S-U-R-F At BSR

Evan Geiselman and Kevin Schulz face off on the Sissy Sauce.


Surfer Of The Year 2020: Michael Ciaramella, Selema Masekela, Ian Crane, Nathan Fletcher, And Jack Robinson

7 days down. 3 more to go.


The Bloody History of Australia’s Best Waves

Surfing and genocide collide at some of Oz’s most iconic spots.


Is this the Best Team in Surfing?

Judge for yourself in their 2020 reel.


Surfer Of The Year 2020: Griffin Colapinto, Italo Ferreira, Stace Galbraith, Connor Coffin, And Coco Ho

Day 6... Eyes are starting to hurt.... The other Intern quit.... Im all alone...


The Big Saturday Content Keeps On A’Comin

Click or Miss Vol.10


Surfer Of The Year 2020: Cam Richards, Albee Layer, Sierra Kerr, Mike February, and Damien Fahrenfort

Half way there, come see who's in the lead.


Tearing Down Walls At J-Bay

Karl Steen gives a lesson on water displacement.


The Smoothest Snap Stall You Ever Did See

Burch, The Tudors and more of San Diego’s finest in Log Rap’s ‘Made You Look’.


Mark Mathews’ 12 Tips To Push Your Big-Wave Limits

Part 3 of 3: Mark Mathews guides us on board choice, accessories and dealing with…


When’s The Last Time You Saw A Blank Nose Move Like This?

Answer for yourself in Connor O'Leary's 'Far East'.


The Secret WSL Flight Set To Save The World Tour

World Tour surfing in 2021 hinges on a sneaky charter flight and two weeks on…


Stab Surfer Of The Year 2020: Tanner Gudauskas, Evan Geiselman, Tom Jennings, Karina Rozunko, And Caroline Marks

"When I first watched that edit, I honestly was so inspired that I rewatched it…


How To Surf Good Waves Sans Crowd

We've cracked the code in this week's edition of the Fwd.


Stab Surfer Of The Year 2020: Parker Coffin, Jimmy Wilson, Matt Meola, Steph Gilmore, And Eric Geiselman

Lark, Jimmicane, the queen, and more.


Stab in The Dark with Taj Burrow, Episode 1 of 4

Featuring 13 unmarked, Dark Arts constructed surfboards.


What In The World Is Chuffed?

Broaden your vocabulary with the latest edit from Joel Paxton.