SUP Pilot Faces Attempted Murder Charge After Weaponising His Paddle  - Stab Mag

Watch Season 2, Episode 10 of How Surfers Get Paid — The Bounty Hunters

3959 Views

SUP Pilot Faces Attempted Murder Charge After Weaponising His Paddle 

The 59-year-old allegedly rear-ended a surfer, stole her board, and forced her underwater.

news // Aug 28, 2025
Words by Jack O'Neill Paterson
Reading Time: < 1 minute

Andrew Eric Gustafson, 59, of Morro Bay, has been charged with two felonies for allegedly turning a SUP into both a battering ram and a bludgeon. According to local news sources, State Parks first booked him for attempted murder, though the DA has since dialled it back, trying to split hairs between surf rage and homicidal tendencies.

After being dissatisfied with how a woman had ridden her wave, witnesses said Gustafson, bipedal, ferociously paddled his craft at a woman surfing, hit her from behind, then graduated from vehicular assault to paddle combat. At around 10:45 a.m. Saturday, he allegedly climbed onto her board, verbally abused her, and then forced her head underwater. All the while, allegedly, his SUP paddle remained in his hand.

The victim declined medical treatment. Gustafson’s bail has been slashed from $550,000 to $25,000, and his next hearing is set for September 3.

Comments

Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up

Advertisement

Most Recent

How Surfers Get Paid: Season 2, Episode 10

The Bounty Hunters.

Jun 23, 2026

An Italian Surfer Is One Heat Away From World #1

Who can stop Leo Fioravanti?

Jun 22, 2026

Can A CT Veteran Fix My Dogshit Roundhouse?

Why adult surf improvement is embarrassing, slow, humbling, and probably worth it.

Jun 22, 2026

How Not To Start A Surf Brand, With Craig Anderson & Dane Reynolds | StabMic Ep. 19

“There were just so many times when we could’ve quit.”

Jun 22, 2026

In Rio There Are No Favourites

Yellow jerseys fall, world champs bow out, and rookies continue their charge toward Finals Day.

Jun 20, 2026

13 World Titles Fall In Saquarema

A backwashy bloodbath at Itaúna.

Jun 19, 2026

How Surfers Get Paid: Where Have We Been?

A new episode is coming. Here's a refresher on our 15 prior shakes of the…

Jun 18, 2026

Can An Economist’s World Cup Equation Predict Who’s Winning Saquarema?

A Vivo Rio Pro preview.

Jun 17, 2026

A 28-Year-Old Roman On Winning His First CT Event

The Stab Interview with Leonardo Fioravanti.

Jun 16, 2026

2026 Surf100 Challenge Series Presented By Pacifico, Episode 02

Our first 100-point ride goes down at wedgy Oceanside Pier. 

Jun 15, 2026

Former Takes The Gloves Off, Drops First Proper Surf Team Film 

“Defect” makes its world premiere in Ventura with 1,000 beers, giveaways and a derby car.

Jun 15, 2026

Dane Reynolds Discusses The Biggest Regrets Of His Surfing Career | StabMic Ep. 18

The lost pilot episode.

Jun 15, 2026

Carissa Moore and Leonardo Fioravanti Collect Contrasting Wins At The 2026 Surf City El Salvador Pro

And despite his runner-up finish, Italo defies all odds.

Jun 14, 2026

Tom Lowe Would Go

From consecutive near-fatal wipeouts to paddling the wave of a lifetime at Mullaghmore.

Jun 13, 2026

Godzilla El Niño… Fact Or Fear-Mongering?

Is it really going to be the end of the world?

Jun 12, 2026

Watch: Ritualistic Tendencies, A Heavyweight Film Of The Year Contender

The eyewear cult releases their first team feature film.

Jun 11, 2026

A One-Legged Italo Is Still Better Than Most Of The CT

Ramzi and Crosby fall to the Wounded Wario and Finals Day is decided.

Jun 11, 2026

Want To Win One Of Ethan Ewing’s Stab In The Dark Boards?

We’re giving away all 12 boards to our Stab Premium members.

Jun 10, 2026
Advertisement