Stab Magazine | Here's a start towards a Shark Solution

Live Now — Episode 3 Of Surf100 Challenge Series Presented By Pacifico

169 Views

Here’s a start towards a Shark Solution

Words by Jed Smith As the world’s leading scientists congregate in Sydney to figure out a solution to the shark problem, here’s a no-brainer of a solution: How about a conclusive study? While sharks have been protected around Australia, and indeed much of the world, for 20 years now, we’ve never had a single scientific fact about shark numbers, their collective behavioural patterns, breeding patterns or migratory patterns to draw on. “Study into Great White Shark populations is very difficult given the uncertainty about their movements, the uncertainty about rates of emigration and immigration from certain areas and the difficulty in estimating the rates of natural or fishing mortality,” explains the Australian Department of Environment, adding, “Accurate population assessments are not yet possible for any region.” And yet authorities still saw fit to lift Great Whites onto the protected list as early as 1982 in South Australia and by 1995 in Queensland, Tasmania, Victoria and Western Australia (they were declared protected at a federal level in 1999). The data used to put them there is questionable to say the least. Specifically, evidence given over by fisherman in the form of game-fishing statistics, commercial by-catch and capture rates in shark nets. None of which rates as scientific, given the countless variables and unknowns that could have skewed the findings. Further confusing the situation was contradictory anecdotal evidence presented at the same time suggesting the juvenile Great White population was on the increase in regions of Victoria. Just last month was Australia given its first “provisional” data on Great White Shark numbers courtesy of a CSIRO report. It put the number of adult whites along the east coast at between 750 and 1200, though it’s a long way from conclusive. “As we get more ­samples, (adult) numbers are tending towards the lower end of this range,” Barry Bruce, head of the National Environmental Science Program, said. “The number is smaller than we thought it may be — but without knowing what the number was in the past, the significance of this is hard to tell.” “What it does not yet tell us though, is whether the population is going up or down.”

news // Mar 8, 2016
Words by Stab
Reading Time: 2 minutes

Words by Jed Smith

As the world’s leading scientists congregate in Sydney to figure out a solution to the shark problem, here’s a no-brainer of a solution: How about a conclusive study? While sharks have been protected around Australia, and indeed much of the world, for 20 years now, we’ve never had a single scientific fact about shark numbers, their collective behavioural patterns, breeding patterns or migratory patterns to draw on.

“Study into Great White Shark populations is very difficult given the uncertainty about their movements, the uncertainty about rates of emigration and immigration from certain areas and the difficulty in estimating the rates of natural or fishing mortality,” explains the Australian Department of Environment, adding, “Accurate population assessments are not yet possible for any region.”

And yet authorities still saw fit to lift Great Whites onto the protected list as early as 1982 in South Australia and by 1995 in Queensland, Tasmania, Victoria and Western Australia (they were declared protected at a federal level in 1999). The data used to put them there is questionable to say the least. Specifically, evidence given over by fisherman in the form of game-fishing statistics, commercial by-catch and capture rates in shark nets. None of which rates as scientific, given the countless variables and unknowns that could have skewed the findings. Further confusing the situation was contradictory anecdotal evidence presented at the same time suggesting the juvenile Great White population was on the increase in regions of Victoria.

Just last month was Australia given its first “provisional” data on Great White Shark numbers courtesy of a CSIRO report. It put the number of adult whites along the east coast at between 750 and 1200, though it’s a long way from conclusive.

“As we get more ­samples, (adult) numbers are tending towards the lower end of this range,” Barry Bruce, head of the National Environmental Science Program, said.

“The number is smaller than we thought it may be — but without knowing what the number was in the past, the significance of this is hard to tell.”

“What it does not yet tell us though, is whether the population is going up or down.”

Comments

Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up

Advertisement

Most Recent

Watch: Rip Curl Mobilises Its Teenage Army In ‘Dunno’

A 30-minute surf film by Vaughan Blakey and Nick Pollet.

Jul 14, 2025

There’s A New Number One Surfer In The World

And it feels so right.

Jul 13, 2025

Controversial Opinion: No One Needs To Yoga In Boardshorts

12 Trunks for the traditionalist.

Jul 13, 2025

Stab Edit Of The Year: Sam Piter Stars in ‘Rogue DNA’.

French blood, thick water.

Jul 13, 2025

Matty McG Skydives Into CT Heat, But Jordy’s Still The Main Event

A full day of heats at J-Bay, and only one shark warning.

Jul 12, 2025

Correction: J-Bay All Foreplay, No Climax

Slim pickings on Day 1 of the Corona Cero Open J-Bay 2025.

Jul 11, 2025

What Do Hollywood, Surf Lessons, Michael Jackson And Traction Pads Have In Common?

A Stab Interview with Teva Dexter, the man behind surfing's hardest new hardware brand —…

Jul 10, 2025

Surf100 Challenge Series Presented By Pacifico: Episode 3

"The tribe has spoken," Dane Reynolds pronounced, and a surfer's torch was snuffed.

Jul 10, 2025

How Josh Ku Nearly Died Trying To Cross From Ulus to G Land by Hydrofoil

“If someone finds me dead at least they can find my phone and know what…

Jul 10, 2025

Expect No Kiss, All Climax At The “World’s Most Perfect Pointbreak”

A Corona Cero Open J-Bay 2025 preview.

Jul 9, 2025

SEOTY: Liam O’Brien stars in ‘Friction of Perception’

"Hopefully I don’t come across like too much of a peanut."

Jul 8, 2025

10 Shapers To Watch In The Next 10 Years — Part One

“It’s like a drug empire, man. Cut the head off the snakes, and more will…

Jul 7, 2025

Mason Ho Joins Ritual Vision, Releases Remix Of Greatest Hits

Dion Agius riffs on the eyewear brand’s U.S. expansion, Ritualistic Tendencies, and the new stars…

Jul 7, 2025

Is It Time For A New Judging Format?

We have a modest proposal — a WSL head judge disagrees.

Jul 7, 2025

Luke Thompson Turns Last Year’s Priority Disaster Into Ballito Gold

+ earns himself a wildcard into Jbay.

Jul 7, 2025

Fiji Has Its First Professional Surfer, And He’s Unbelievable

16-year-old James Kusitino’s incomprehensible tube lounging leads to a deal with Former.

Jul 6, 2025

Laird Hamilton on The Limitations of Being a Purist, Invention vs. Ownership + Why He Never Had a Sticker Deal 

Untold stories from his How Surfers Get Paid interview.

Jul 4, 2025

When Surfer’s Eye Is Actually Cancer

Erin Campbell's brutal journey from surf camp dreams to chemo drops, cryotherapy, and surgical horror.

Jul 3, 2025
Advertisement