Stab Magazine | Facebook vs Kauai

Live Now — Episode 3 Of Surf100 Challenge Series Presented By Pacifico

273 Views

Facebook vs Kauai

Zuckerberg sues native Hawaiians.

news // Jan 20, 2017
Words by Stab
Reading Time: 3 minutes

Facebook’s mission statement: “Facebook’s mission is to give people the power to share and make the world more open and connected.”

Company founder and billionaire Mark Zuckerberg just filed multiple lawsuits to remove over a dozen native Hawaiian families from his 700-acre “family sanctuary” on Kauai. Apparently, he’s more of a “do as I say not as I do” kind of guy.

Two years ago, the Zuck, paid approximately $100 million for the beachfront property on the Garden Isle. On the land lived a number of “kamaaina” families, who by Hawaiian law, have the right to live on the tech tycoon’s oversized retreat.

Directly translated, “kamaʻāina” means “child of the land,” and the idea of these native families having rights to their ancestral home dates back to the Kuleana Act of 1850. In a coconut shell, the act dealt with the issue of private land ownership in the Hawaiian kingdom. Typically, land was passed down to heirs over the generations. In some cases today, those descendants have retained property without any official documentation. The legal parlance is often referred to “quiet title and partition”, and it is relatively common in the Islands. Zuck’s lawsuits intend to force these families to sell off their lands at a public auction (with the highest bidder presumably being him). Really, how’s going to outbid the CEO of Facebook who Forbes estimates is worth $44.6 billion? 

 

big

Here’s Mark pondering what you do when you can’t acquire Snapchat. 

“Partition by sale, in particular, is highly problematic for the Native Hawaiian community because it severs a family’s connection to ancestral land,” reads a Center for Excellence in Native Hawaiian Law that was cited by the Honolulu Star Advertiser, which initially broke the story. 
On December 30, 2016, Zuckerberg’s shadow companies—Pilaa International LLC, Northshore Kalo LLC and High Flyer LLC — filed eight “quiet title” lawsuits in state Circuit Court on Kauai. Some of the people he’s suing are alive, including native Hawaiian women named Oma, Eliza Kauhaahaa and Annie I. He’s also trying to razz the dead, with suits against “long-deceased defendants” Kelekahi, Palaha, Laka, Lote, Luliana, Kapahu and Kaluuloa. It’s believed in some cases there are no rightful living heirs, but that remains to be seen as this process plays out.

There is also a case against 300 descendants from a Portuguese sugar cane plantation worker named Manuel Rapozo. The complaint states he bought four parcels (about two acres) in 1894. Rapozo’s great-grandson, Carlos Andrade, a retired University of Hawaii professor of Hawaiian studies, has joined Zuckerberg as a co-plaintiff. He lived on the kuleana land from 1977 until recently, but continues to maintain a house and garden there.

zuj sup

SUP Zuck.

“I feel that each succeeding generation will become owners of smaller and smaller interests, each having less and less percentage of the lands and less and less capability to make sure everyone gets their fair share of (Rapozo’s) investment in the future of his family,” wrote Andrade in a letter to relatives explaining his view of the matter. 

He estimates that a large majority of his relatives were unaware of the land and lawsuits. Mind you, we’re talking about fractions of property rights that could be one-half of one percent or smaller. Putting a valuation on the shares has been difficult. Based on property records, Zuckerberg paid $8,607 for 1/100 a share and $350 for 1/3,276 of a share. 
Genealogical evidence will play a role in determining who’s entitled to what. Then it’s up to the judge how to proceed in the cases against one of the richest men in the world and a small group of native Hawaiians. In regards to the eight quiet title cases on Kauai, should the property go to auction, if you’ve got the money to go toe to toe with Zuck, and step up.

Comments

Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up

Advertisement

Most Recent

Correction: J-Bay All Foreplay, No Climax

Slim pickings on Day 1 of the Corona Cero Open J-Bay 2025.

Jul 11, 2025

What Do Hollywood, Surf Lessons, Michael Jackson And Traction Pads Have In Common?

A Stab Interview with Teva Dexter, the man behind surfing's hardest new hardware brand —…

Jul 10, 2025

Surf100 Challenge Series Presented By Pacifico: Episode 3

"The tribe has spoken," Dane Reynolds pronounced, and a surfer's torch was snuffed.

Jul 10, 2025

How Josh Ku Nearly Died Trying To Cross From Ulus to G Land by Hydrofoil

“If someone finds me dead at least they can find my phone and know what…

Jul 10, 2025

Expect No Kiss, All Climax At The “World’s Most Perfect Pointbreak”

A Corona Cero Open J-Bay 2025 preview.

Jul 9, 2025

SEOTY: Liam O’Brien stars in ‘Friction of Perception’

"Hopefully I don’t come across like too much of a peanut."

Jul 8, 2025

10 Shapers To Watch In The Next 10 Years — Part One

“It’s like a drug empire, man. Cut the head off the snakes, and more will…

Jul 7, 2025

Mason Ho Joins Ritual Vision, Releases Remix Of Greatest Hits

Dion Agius riffs on the eyewear brand’s U.S. expansion, Ritualistic Tendencies, and the new stars…

Jul 7, 2025

Is It Time For A New Judging Format?

We have a modest proposal — a WSL head judge disagrees.

Jul 7, 2025

Luke Thompson Turns Last Year’s Priority Disaster Into Ballito Gold

+ earns himself a wildcard into Jbay.

Jul 7, 2025

Fiji Has Its First Professional Surfer, And He’s Unbelievable

16-year-old James Kusitino’s incomprehensible tube lounging leads to a deal with Former.

Jul 6, 2025

Laird Hamilton on The Limitations of Being a Purist, Invention vs. Ownership + Why He Never Had a Sticker Deal 

Untold stories from his How Surfers Get Paid interview.

Jul 4, 2025

When Surfer’s Eye Is Actually Cancer

Erin Campbell's brutal journey from surf camp dreams to chemo drops, cryotherapy, and surgical horror.

Jul 3, 2025

Surfing’s 2025 Q2 Report

An assessment of surfing's vital signs throughout the second quarter of 2025.

Jul 2, 2025

What Actually Happened to Occy’s Mad Max Plunger Pool In Yeppoon?

Surf Lakes’ brass talks: internet hecklers, the unplugging of the plunger, and the Tom Curren…

Jul 2, 2025

Poor Goofy Foots 

Data shows that the world is stacked against goofs — they even make 15% less money than…

Jul 1, 2025

Britain’s First Wavepool Has Closed — What Really Happened?

Bankruptcy, social media hackings, debts unpaid — and yet, reopening looms.

Jul 1, 2025

Watch: Was Matt Meola’s Air Actually Better Than Hughie’s?

Watch the full Swatch Nines highlight reel and decide.

Jun 30, 2025
Advertisement