A Proposed Seawall Threatens A Beloved Australian Beachie - Stab Mag

Live Now: Chapter 11 Mini-Documentary With Dane Reynolds

593 Views

A Proposed Seawall Threatens A Beloved Australian Beachie

Erosion at Wamberal is getting exponentially worse, but many locals believe a seawall is not the answer.

news // Dec 11, 2020
Words by Jake Embrey
Reading Time: 3 minutes

For decades houses along Wamberal’s shore have faced the threat of being washed into the sea. Two hours north of Sydney’s hustle and bustle, Wamberal is a coastal suburb home to hundreds, if not thousands, of surfers who’ve cut their teeth along it’s two-kilometre stretch of sand. You would be hard pressed to find a surfer who grew up on the Central Coast who doesn’t have at least one memorable session here – I know I have a few.

While the issue of erosion has been on the minds of home owners at Wamberal for years, the recent spate of large swells reiterated the fact this issue was urgent and would not resolve itself. Thirty metres of beach was washed away in mid-July after an East Coast Low and 18 of the 60 houses along the shore were indefinitely evacuated  as a result. 

One proposed solution – supported by many of the aforementioned home owners – is to construct a seawall. There is however vocal opposition to the proposed wall, many of whom have joined the Facebook group Wamberal Beach Save Our Sand; a group which is also angered by the exclusion of other local residents and the Surf Live Saving Club from initial discussions about a wall.

In short, while the majority of the 60 homeowners along Wamberal’s waterfront are in favour of a wall, there are thousands of other locals who are opposed. Both groups want to reduce erosion and maintain Wamberal’s essence*, their disagreement is over the best method of doing so. 

A report by Marsden Jacobs outlines eight different options. Option one is maintaining the status quo, options two to seven involve various types of seawalls, and the eighth option involves a Planned Retreat which would “manage the duration, type and intensity of future development in the coastal hazard area”. 

“[N]one of the engineering options considered provided a net public benefit for the local community.” The Guardian’s summary of the report read. “This is because all of the seawall options would result in the loss of beach areas, and without sand replenishment the beach would quickly disappear, with significant costs to the local tourism industry.

“[I]t was not clear which seawall option would lead to the fastest loss of the beach but all would result in an unusable beach by 2064, without a major sand replenishment program.”

According to the report by Marsden Jacobs, some of the 60 homes immediately threatened will be protected by a seawall, but in the long term more homes will be endangered by rising sea levels in both Terrigal and Wamberal lagoon. 

“The CBA shows that of all the options considered, Option 8 is the only option that will provide a net gain in economic welfare for the residents of the Central Coast.” The conclusion of the report reads. “The speed with which the beach will be lost will vary with the type of seawall involved. The council proposed rubble mound revetment (Options 2 and 3) will result in immediate loss of most of the beach in winter. Vertical seawall designs (Options 6 and 7) only have a two to three metre footprint, but their design means that the rate of sand erosion is faster than with a rubble mound revetment.”

On a whole, those served to benefit from a potential seawall are those homeowners on the waterfront. When the entire community is taken into account, all reports found there to be no net benefit for the greater community. Furthermore, if the majority of the sand will be swept away, there is little hope for Wamberal’s sand banks and the waves which break upon them to be unaffected. Locals have reported that makeshift concrete barriers are already influencing wave quality at the beach.   

Despite this, the local council seems to be leaning towards the side of the seawall, with additional studies being undergone at the expense of the taxpayer; for example, a study being run by Manly Hydraulic Laboratory will cost the Central Coast Council and state government upwards of $400,000. If the seawall were to be built, estimates at the production cost are in the tens of millions. 

Option 8 may involve buying back the homes and lands of the current owners at threat – a cost itself which would be in the hundreds of millions if all 60 homes were to be re-purchased – and have a Planned Retreat. The council had the opportunity to do this in the 70’s after previous mass erosion events, but decided not to, instead opting for continued development.

The issue of erosion is going to be a costly affair for councils and governments around the world in years to come as sea levels rise and storms worsen as a result of global warming. If one thing is clear it is that a decision needs to be made, and preferably one which is directed by the science and benefits the community as a whole – not just a handful of wealthy and influential individuals. 

*A more sceptical view would be that the wealthy homeowners are interested in the immediate impact on themselves and their houses rather than the beach/community as a whole. 

Comments

Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up

Advertisement

Most Recent

Watch: What Happens When A Brand Takes Its Youth Team To A CT Event?

A: Good things, typically.

Mar 29, 2024

Full Frame: Scandinavia Is Surfing’s Next Frontier

A 30-hour drive, bathymetric maps, and 10 years of searching yield surfing's newest discovery.

Mar 29, 2024

Watch: João Chianca Had A Remarkable Hawaii Season Before His Injury

Plus an update on his condition.

Mar 28, 2024

Pittar’d And Feathered

Do the WSL judges deserve the internet's wrath? We asked the man of the hour.

Mar 28, 2024

Robbo, Pickles, And Tyler Wright Become The Underdogs Breakfast At Uninspiring Winkipop

The foreboding blade sharpens and inconsistent judging prevails on Day Two in Torquay.

Mar 27, 2024

“I Don’t Always Win Heats, But When I Do, I Try To Beat John John”

Slater shines and the axe begins its descent on Day 01 at Bells.

Mar 26, 2024

Back Against The Wall: The Ramzi Boukhiam Redemption

Morocco's first CT surfer on speaking six languages, having no coach, and snatching Fil Toledo's…

Mar 25, 2024

Will Kirra, Babies or JJF Stop a GOAT Winning at Bells?

Bluesky BOAG advice from a Superman specialist and former Trials winner.

Mar 25, 2024

Bells Preview: The WSL’s Victorian Sword Dancing Equinox Ritual

Will a Brazilian crack the Top 10 at Bells?

Mar 25, 2024

69 Shin Bones Later + the Anticlimactic State of Big Wave Record-Breaking

Lucas Chumbo might have surfed the biggest wave ever this year. But how will we…

Mar 23, 2024

Watch: ‘Fresh and Fried’ Ft the Quik Kids

How taxing is it to tackle the Gold Coast’s Triple Crown in a single day,…

Mar 23, 2024

The Popular Vote: The People’s Stab In The Dark With Kolohe Andino Champion

Which board looked best — to you —under Kolohe's talons?

Mar 22, 2024

Six Key Learnings From Portugal

Three CT events in, what do we know? 

Mar 21, 2024

‘Zipper’ Is Going On Tour, Here’s Where You Can Watch It  

Dates, times + locations for the Venice, Encinitas, Sydney + Byron premieres.  

Mar 20, 2024

Dane Reynolds On His Future, His Past, And Chapter 11’s Raison D’être

Our 9-minute plunge into the collective psyche of Ventura's pillar(s).

Mar 20, 2024

From ‘Blue Ribbon Cross Country Runner’ to Vogue – How Steph Again Is Back With A Rip Curl Remix

Everything we know about the she-GOATs sponsorship boomerang.

Mar 18, 2024

Stab Interview: Darren Handley Explains Why You Can’t Buy The Winning Stab In The Dark Model

And his decades-long standoff with Slater.

Mar 17, 2024

Griff Embraces Portugal’s Eternal Time Loop To Vanquish Medina + Ewing, Defay Delays The Inevitable

A redeeming closing act at Supertubos.

Mar 16, 2024
Advertisement