Suspect Charged For Fatal Stabbing Of Young Coffs Harbour Surfer  - Stab Mag
1725 Views

Suspect Charged For Fatal Stabbing Of Young Coffs Harbour Surfer 

21-YO Kye Schaefer was killed getting changed into his wetsuit at 6:40 in the morning.

elsewhere // Jun 5, 2024
Words by Stab
Reading Time: 2 minutes

A man has been charged with the alleged murder of 21-year-old surfer Kye Schaefer, following a month-long investigation. Schaefer was fatally stabbed on May 2 at the Park Beach Reserve car park in Coffs Harbour, New South Wales.

Schaefer, who had been surfing at a nearby spot known as “Parkie,” was still in his wetsuit when he was found with multiple stab wounds. Emergency services were called to the scene, and Schaefer was taken to a hospital, where he later died from his injuries.

The investigation, led by the New South Wales State Crime Command Homicide Squad, resulted in the arrest of 36-year-old Matthew Willacy. According to reports by the Australian Associated Press, Willacy was known to police and is believed to be homeless and living in the area. He has also been charged in connection with an unrelated robbery that occurred around the same time and location as Schaefer’s attack.

Credit: Britt Ramsey/ABC news

Homicide Squad Commander Daniel Doherty commended the efforts of both homicide detectives and the Coffs-Clarence Police District. “It’s been a month’s worth of dedicated, determined investigative work,” Doherty said. The evidence gathered includes witness accounts, CCTV footage, and forensic analysis, which Doherty described as forming a strong circumstantial case.

The investigation remains ongoing, and police are urging anyone with information or dash cam footage to come forward. Authorities are still searching for the murder weapon and a bicycle that Willacy was believed to be riding on the morning of the stabbing.

As for the motive, Doherty suggested in an interview with Sydney radio 2GB that the attack may have been a robbery gone wrong, describing it as “unprovoked and violent.”

Willacy appeared briefly in Coffs Harbour Local Court on Tuesday and is scheduled to return to court on August 13.

Comments

Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up

Advertisement

Most Recent

A 15-Year-Old Snowboard Phenom + A 3-Minute Tube Hunter Walk Into StabMic

“If I didn’t have a GoPro, no one would believe me,” says Koa Smith.

Mar 21, 2026

Stab Interview: Israel’s First CT Surfer

Anat Lelior on military service, online hate, and her unique path to professional surfing.

Mar 19, 2026

Watch: Episode Two Of ‘VELA’ Featuring John John Florence

This time with Nate, Ivan, and another untouched reef pass.

Mar 19, 2026

So, What Do CT Surfers Think About Manu Bay?

A scene report from the Tasman Sea with Jack Robinson, Connor O’Leary, Luke Cederman, and…

Mar 18, 2026

What’s It Actually Like Surfing Mundaka?

A day in the life of a non-local goofy.

Mar 17, 2026

How To: Quit Professional Surfing

At what point do you walk away from the endless QS > CS > CT…

Mar 17, 2026

Why Did 50 Men Just March Into The Sahara With Surfboards And Moroccan Flags?

The story of a decades-old feud and the desert wave it exposed.

Mar 15, 2026

Meet The 2026 Qualifying Class

The CS is done; the CT begins in two weeks.

Mar 15, 2026

SEOTY: Imaikalani deVault Stars In ‘Little Bits’

"He pretty much got to the CT on talent alone.”

Mar 13, 2026

JJF + Dane Reynolds Recall The Best Session Of Their Lives

"It felt like you could do anything you wanted.”

Mar 13, 2026

86% Of Women’s CS Qualifiers Are Currently From Europe

Who are 'Euroforce Femme' and where did they come from?

Mar 11, 2026

Watch: Episode One Of ‘VELA’ Featuring John John Florence

A perfect empty right, a shallow empty left, and one 3x World Champ.

Mar 11, 2026

Unlocked: Brody Mulik Stars In ‘fourteen.’

Homeschooled at The Box and Tombies, the fifteen-year-old might be Western Australia's best student.

Mar 11, 2026

Watch: Patti Zhou In Her Element(s)

Snow, water, but mostly air.

Mar 11, 2026

Watch: Quiksilver’s King Of The Groms Final

Kash Brown, Mananalu Chandler, Brody Mulik, and Dylan Donegan try to freesurf their way into…

Mar 11, 2026

Ethan Ewing: The Next Stab In The Dark Star

Back to first principles, with modern horsepower.

Mar 10, 2026

Where Are Surfing’s Next Male Superstars?

Young women are dominating pro surfing, while the men’s tour ages. Why?

Mar 9, 2026

John Florence Is About To Capture The Attention Of The Entire Surf World (Again)

This is why the 3x World Champ won't be returning to the tour.

Mar 9, 2026
Advertisement