Gabriel Medina Gives Scathing Review Of WSL Judging After Controversial Surf Ranch Final - Stab Mag

EAST with Harry Bryant coming August 18...

2503 Views

Gabriel Medina Gives Scathing Review Of WSL Judging After Controversial Surf Ranch Final

‘The surf community has been mesmerized by the poor clarity and consistency of judging for many years now, but lately it has been even more shocking.’

news // May 29, 2023
Words by Ethan Davis
Reading Time: 2 minutes

Scalding hot. 

Less than an hour after the Surf Ranch finals concluded, three time World Champion Gabriel Medina issued a statement on Instagram calling out WSL judges for ‘mesmerizing inconsistencies’ in scoring that ‘threaten to draw fans, sponsors and athletes away’.

A PR pickle alright.

Per his latest IG post:

“Dear WSL,

Please understand the importance of this discussion. 

Surfing has been my life and my love for this sport is unconditional. I have put all my heart into and and want to leave a beautiful legacy one day when I look back at it. 

However the surfing community, especially in Brazil, is mesmerized with the poor clarity and inconsistence of judging for many years now, but lately it has been even more shocking.

It is quite clear that judging is now rewarding very simple surfing, seamless transitions and have taken critical turns in critical sections off the criteria. This is very frustrating and is stagnating the sport. 

Fans and sponsors will not accept this to continue and will in a near future be drawn away once all they want is equal and fair judging to the sport. 

Also, important to note that many coaches and managers have had the opportunity to speak to WSL after heats/events to ask about PROGRESSION and VARIETY in the criteria and the lack of reward for this space. The response given by them is always quite defensive by giving poor examples to illustrate THEIR point.

WSL needs urgently to clarify judging and apply equal and fair judging to save the progression of the sport.”

Ooft.

As a side note, Gabriel Medina has 11.1 million followers on instagram, compared with the WSL’s 3.9. Almost three times the size.

You could fit 10 Stab followings inside Gabe Medina. That’s why non-endemic brands like Gillette pay him thousands to shave his armpits and not us. He is a super star.

“I’ve always felt like I’ve needed to surf three times as good as the others just to get the same score,” Italo told us in Stab in the Dark. (Photo by Pat Nolan/World Surf League)

In the men’s final many viewers, myself included, felt Italo Ferreira was undercooked in the final against Griffin Colapinto, which inevitably triggered strong reactions from surf fans.

The comments section of the WSL’s winner post has since amassed ~10K comments, mostly from Brazilians, fingering the judges for dodgy scoring.

Ethan Ewing’s DMs. Can you imagine what Griff’s currently look like? I wonder who will follow Kelly’s lead in ‘getting injured’ before Brazil.

A tough day ahead for Pritamo and the Wozzle’s media team.

More to come.

Comments

Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up

Advertisement

Most Recent

2026 Surf100 Challenge Series Presented By Pacifico, Episode 06

100 points decides our first finalist.

Aug 10, 2026

Mason Ho On Farming, Andy Irons, And The Day He Punched Kelly Slater | StabMic Ep. 26

"Farming is completely opening my brain."

Aug 10, 2026

Kelly’s Quinquagenarian Dominance, Eli’s Gumption, And Eimeo’s Upset

Three takeaways from six heats on Day 1 at the Outerknown Tahiti Pro.

Aug 9, 2026

Hossegor Beach Cocaine Episode 1: Y2K To Infinity

A new Stab Premium podcast series.

Aug 7, 2026

Take Stab’s 2027 Audience Survey, (Maybe) Win A Trip To Kandui

...and two custom surfboards.

Aug 6, 2026

Biblical Swell To Greet The Youngest, Oldest, And Most Unhinged Wildcards In Teahupo’o History

A Tahiti Pro preview.

Aug 6, 2026

SEOTY: Michael Dunphy and His Fantastic Flying Machine Star in ‘Stream East’

To the Caribbean and beyond.

Aug 5, 2026

Can A Stab Writer Make One Heat In A QS2000?

We're about to find out.

Aug 5, 2026

Investigation: The $24 Million Plan To Kill Shark’s Cove

Eight local businesses sit in the crosshairs of the North Shore's Karen-Elite.

Aug 3, 2026

Remembering Arran Strong

Friends, family, and the surfing world remember a waterman who truly lived every day like…

Aug 3, 2026

CT Surfers Ate 80% Of The US Open’s Semifinal Points

Jake Marshall and Sierra Kerr won Huntington. The men’s result also reopened the Challenger Series’…

Aug 3, 2026

Jamie O’Brien Doesn’t Believe Pro Surfers Are Core | StabMic Ep. 25

"When people forget your value, it's time to forget about them."

Aug 3, 2026

Tosh Tudor on Foamball Spirituality, Giving Up Weed, And Learnings From His Father

Veteran surf journo Matt George caught up with Tosh in between Indonesian sessions.

Aug 1, 2026

Watch: Ryan Callinan in ‘Interim’ 

What has your favorite surfer’s favorite goofyfoot been up to?

Jul 31, 2026

Can Karma Decide Who Wins A Surf Contest?

If last year's Rip Curl Padang Cup is anything to go by, don't rule it…

Jul 30, 2026

Surf100 Changed My Mind About Zeke Lau

How does our production team really feel about the 6'2 Hawaiian?

Jul 29, 2026

Why CT Surfers Threatened To Boycott The ISA World Games

And how it will affect the level of surfing in the 2028 Olympics.

Jul 29, 2026

What’s Coming To Stab Premium 

The hard drive-release pipeline for the next five months.

Jul 28, 2026
Advertisement