WSL CEO Erik Logan Responds To ‘Unfair Judging’ Claims In Open Letter - Stab Mag

Live Now: How Surfers Get Paid — The Queens of Ascension

0 View

WSL CEO Erik Logan Responds To ‘Unfair Judging’ Claims In Open Letter

“It is a breach of league policy, for surfers to choose not to engage with the proper process and instead air grievances on social media.”

// May 30, 2023
Words by Ethan Davis
Reading Time: 4 minutes

Shortly after the Surf Ranch final, 3x World Champ Gabriel Medina told his 11.1M followers on social media that there was ‘poor clarity and consistency’ regarding the WSL’s judging that ‘threaten to draw away athletes, fans and sponsors’.

In the days after, two more Brazilian World Champs, Italo Ferreira and Filipe Toledo, who together account for five out of the past eight World Titles made statements of their own, overlapping in many concerns. 

This coincided with a bunch of nasty comments targeted at WSL staffers, athletes and employees, not limited to threats of violence and death. 

The WSL has finally fired back, addressing not just their concerns over the fairness of the judging, but also the resulting damage caused by airing their grievances online. 

How hot’s the water Gabby’s swimming in?

“To the WSL community,

I want to address the conversation that happened in our community following the recent Championship Tour event at the Surf Ranch. As you likely know, a small number of athletes made statements questioning the judging of the competition and the final results.

I want to respond directly to those statements, however, we first need to address a much more important issue. In recent days, a number of surfers, WSL judges, and employees have been subject to harassment, intimidation, and threats of violence, including death threats, as a direct result of those statements. Those things should never happen in our sport or any sport, and we’re devastated that members of our community have been subject to them. It is an important reminder to us all that words have consequences. We hope the entire WSL community stands with us in rejecting all forms of harassment and intimidation.

In terms of the statements made, we completely reject the suggestion that the judging of our competitions is in any way unfair or biased. These claims are not supported by any evidence.

Firstly, the judging criteria are provided to the athletes ahead of each competition. All athletes competing at the Surf Ranch Pro received these materials on May 20th. Every athlete had the opportunity to ask questions about the criteria at that time. None of the athletes who made these statements took advantage of this opportunity at the Surf Ranch Pro.

Secondly, our rules allow any athlete to review the scoring of any wave, with the judges, and receive a more detailed explanation of how they were scored with the judges. This process has been in place for a number of years, and is the direct result of working with the surfers to bring more transparency to the judging process. It is not acceptable, and is a breach of league policy, for surfers to choose not to engage with the proper process and instead air grievances on social media.

A number of athletes at the Surf Ranch Pro received points for elements such as progression and variety, so it is simply incorrect to suggest these are not taken into account in the judging criteria. Furthermore, our rules have been applied consistently throughout the season, including at events this season that were won by athletes who are now questioning those same rules.

Surfing is an ever-evolving, subjective sport and we welcome a robust debate around the progression of our sport and the criteria used to judge our competitions. However, it is unacceptable for any athlete to question the integrity of our judges who, like our surfers, are elite professionals.

No one person or group of people are above the integrity of the sport. Sincerely,

Erik Logan
WSL Chief Executive Officer

You can read Filipe’s statement here. (Photo by Aaron Hughes/World Surf League)

Wow. “It is an important reminder to us all that words have consequences,” has some pretty serious go-to-war vibes about it. Side note: I reckon E Lo could write a pretty banging speech in Succession. 

Per the WSL’s rule book, all three surfers would be in a breach of the ‘Conduct Policy’ guidelines which permit athletes from “making derogatory comments on social media”. Surfers in violation of this code can be subject to either or all of the following disciplinary actions:

(i)  Monetary Fines and Disqualification. The monetary fine amounts for an offense of this Rule range from $1,000 USD to $50,000 USD per offense.

(ii)  Suspension and Expulsion. Any offender under this Rule may be subject to suspension and/or expulsion from a WSL Tour upon the first offense. Where multiple offenses occur within one (1) or more concurrent seasons which demonstrate a pattern of unacceptable conduct, the Surfer may also be subject to suspension and/or expulsion from the WSL.

How harsh a penalty Medina receives is yet to be determined. However, I would think ‘suspension’ and/or ‘expulsion’ is off the table. 

Hold tight. (Photo by Pat Nolan/World Surf League)

This is not the first time Erik has needed to respond to a mutiny. Last year after Bells he wrote an open letter responding to a petition signed by 29 (out of 51) current CT surfers asking the WSL to reconsider the mid-year cut or face boycotting the event at Margaret River. 

The most striking thing to me is that these surfer’s, who’s following far exceeds that of the WSL, are in positions of incredible power as far as their reach is concerned. In the aftermath, it would have been great to see more denounce threats of violence, particularly ahead of the Brazil event. 

Listen to our recent Stab podcast between Stace and Mikey for a deep dive on the controversy.


Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up


Most Recent

Swell’s En Route, Slater’s Involved, Here Comes Teahupo’o… 

A Tahiti Pro preview.

May 22, 2024

Can Medina Overcome His CT Drought In Tahiti?

Tahurai Henry offers his picks for the SHISEIDO Tahiti Pro

May 21, 2024

The 35 Best Song Pairings In Surf Films, As Ranked By Dane Reynolds, Taylor Steele & You

From Noa Deane and Courtney Love, to Andy Irons and Coldplay, to Creed McTaggart and…

May 20, 2024

Is This The Most Cost Efficient Way To Noticeably Improve Your Surfing In A Single Month?

All you can eat for $1500 AUD at URBNSURF Melbourne.

May 20, 2024

Watch And Learn: How To Score A Solo Sesh At 8-Foot Teahupo’o With Leonardo Fioravanti

Skip lunch and gorge.

May 19, 2024

Full Frame: The Story Behind The Photo You’ve Seen 1,000 Times

A viral ménage à trois in Bali.

May 18, 2024

Meet The Man Who Runs Kelly Slater’s Burgeoning Surf Empire

The Stab Interview with Dylan Slater. 

May 18, 2024

How Surfers Get Paid: Season 2, Episode 4

80+ interviews later, it's time to "send out the chicks".

May 17, 2024

How To Get To Stab High Japan

BYO ligaments. 

May 16, 2024

CT Earlybirds, Tahitian Warlords, And Aspirational Teenagers Divide Spoils From “11 out of 10” Teahupo’o Blob

Eimeo Czermak, Balaram Stack, Liam O'Brien, Cannon Carr, and Ryan Miller divulge tales from the…

May 16, 2024

The Lefts Off The Rights

Detailing the goofy-footed proclivity to go against the grain.

May 15, 2024

Watch: ‘Shotgun’ featuring Josie Prendergast & Taj Richmond

The allure of contradiction, displayed in the virtue of Northern Rivers sand.

May 15, 2024

How Accurate Were Our Pre-Cut Predictions?

Reflecting on the rookie-centric forecasts offered by CJ Hobgood, Stace Galbraith, Brett Simpson, and Mikey…

May 14, 2024

Local Wildcard Jordy Lawler Dusts 79 Transplants, Issy Nichols Denies Prodigy Erin Brooks Another Plush Toy

The Stab High winner is one semi-final away from tour qualification after only two events.

May 14, 2024

Which 2024 Stab High Competitor Has Given Us The Best Surf Part?  

Noa Deane, Chippa Wilson, Julian Wilson, Ian Crane and more duel for the most impactful…

May 13, 2024

There Are Still Perfect, Empty Waves Left In The World

Soli Bailey, Timo Simmers + Layne Stratton on the sand-bottomed unicorn seen in ‘Maps to…

May 13, 2024

What Happened To Bali?

And is an ethical future for surf development possible in Indonesia?

May 12, 2024

Premium Peek: Mason Ho + Sheldon Paishon Vs A Scottish Widow Maker

Less like a wave, more like a German Panzer tank (180 tons, FYI).

May 12, 2024