Stab Magazine | Who Combo'd It Better, Kelly Slater, Kolohe Andino or Jordy Smith?

Who Combo’d It Better, Kelly Slater, Kolohe Andino or Jordy Smith?

Dissecting the tube to oops of 2014, 2015 and 2016. 

Words by stab

Apparently a cocktail of Chia seeds, Purps and a DIY wave is the fountain of youth. Kelly Slater, at 44, is still at the forefront of progression. It’s amazing his knees haven’t given out. Even while his competitive mindset evaded him, his freesurfing remained one of a kind. There’s no hyperbole fit for Kelly’s career; he’s our Jordan, Gretzky, and Jeter. Yesterday at Backdoor, a bit before John Florence projected an alley-oop that’ll spark debate over the biggest air in history, Mr Slater threw his hat into a category popularised by Kolohe Andino’s Portuguese drainer to oop back in 2014. Which was then backed by Jordy’s in August of 2015.

So, as we’re a judging group by nature, let’s analyse these three waves of similarity:
In a streak of down days, onshore winds and non-contestable surf, late yesterday morning it started to clean up. Backdoor produced some possibly-maybes, and they teased calling on the event. They didn’t, but the freesurf that transpired saw Kelly Slater joining the deep tube to oop club (filmed by Ryan Perry). Kelly’s wave was smaller than both gent’s. However his barrel was long, tight and critical.

Jordy’s (filmed by Nick Green) compared to Kelly’s had shorter travel time through the barrel, but the pumps exerted before the cover up gave him the speed to go as high as he did on the air section. What’s unique about Jordy’s is the hang time, how he shifts in the wind and spots the double up section which aids as a runway.

Then Kolohe’s (filmed by Noah Alani) in Portugal might just stand superior. The barrel was deep, long and he pulled up just in time to avoid the pinch. Then had the wherewithal to find the ramp section and nearly clear what a world tour surfer would have trouble floating over. He doesn’t land as clean as Kelly or Jordy, but that adds a bit to the aesthetic.

Who’s was best? Well, surfing’s subjective but that’s what the Disqus is for. 


Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up


Most Recent

Would You Ride A Hemp Surfboard?

If so, here’s your chance to win a freebie from SOLID.

Oct 27, 2021

Should Championship Tour Surfers Compete On The Challenger Series?

Given the new wildcard rule, questions of morality loom. So we posed them to Kanoa…

Oct 27, 2021


Mikey February Won’t Leave Costa Rica Until His New Board Is Dialed

The proper setting for a talk with your shaper.

Oct 27, 2021

The Strange Intimacy Of An Almost Empty Lineup

Misc: Just the two of us.

Oct 26, 2021

Did Australian Surfing Just Get Its Mongrel Back?

Connor O'Leary may be the nicest guy in pro surfing, but his recent win revived…

Oct 26, 2021

Koa Smith Pleas For WSL 2022 Ultimate Surfer Wildcards After Zeke Lau Officially Qualifies Via CS

"The Ultimate Surfer wildcards are floating around up in the air, up for grabs."

Oct 26, 2021

Inside The Thai Factory Where Your Surfboard Might Have Been Made

“It sort of made me frightened for the Australian surfboard industry.”

Oct 25, 2021


“The Most Spooked Out I’ve Felt In A Very Long Time”

The Coopers Pacific Pale Ale Odyssey heads to the Indian Ocean.

Oct 25, 2021

Morgan Maassen Talks Creative Processes & The Production Of His Latest Work, ‘Goddesses’

A serene portrait of three Polynesian sisters pushing their surfing to the limits.

Oct 25, 2021

The Picasso Of Social Media Surf Skits Reveals The Tear-Shed Moment He Confronted Girlfriend With Outrageous Stab Highway Hairdo

Mckenzie Bowden had to quarantine in the doghouse.

Oct 25, 2021


Unlocked For All: Asher Pacey In ‘No Straight Lines’

He draws many lines — and, as promised, none of them are straight.

Oct 25, 2021

Are We Due For Another Perfect Wave Discovery?

Short answer: yeah.

Oct 24, 2021


Watch: Another Young Talent Springs Out Of Florianópolis

Wallace Vasco bleeds undeniable shades of Yago Dora.

Oct 23, 2021

The Challenger Series Rankings Just Got a Savage Shake-up

Brisa Hennessy and Connor O'Leary win the Quik/Roxy Pro France

Oct 23, 2021

What’s Your Favorite Song + Surf Section Pairing Of All Time?

An exercise in unabashed subjectivity.

Oct 23, 2021

If One Deceased Surfbrand Deserved Resuscitating It’s Most Certainly Gotcha

Surf Core Heritage not thought up in a focus group.

Oct 22, 2021

Stab Podcast: How Many Waves Counts As A Session?

Conspiracy theories, wildcard fiascos, and an inception-like surf sin.

Oct 22, 2021

‘Drive-Thru’ Team Buys Rights Back To Iconic Surf Series, Plans To Start Filming In November

Benji Weatherly explains how he, Donavon Frankenreiter, Greg Browning, and Taylor Steele plan to take…

Oct 22, 2021