Stab Magazine | What's The Purpose Behind The WSL's The "Drop Your Two Lowest Scores" Rule, And How Does It Affect Our World Champions?

Live Now — Episode 3 Of Surf100 Challenge Series Presented By Pacifico

362 Views

What’s The Purpose Behind The WSL’s The “Drop Your Two Lowest Scores” Rule, And How Does It Affect Our World Champions?

Bonus trivia: which surfer has been singly cursed by this long-held sanction?

news // Nov 5, 2019
Words by Stab
Reading Time: 4 minutes

We recently discussed how the WSL’s “drop your two lowest event scores” rule perceptually decreased Carissa Moore’s World Title lead heading into both Portugal And Honolua. 

While Carissa appeared to have an 8,000-point lead over Lakey Peterson heading into the Rip Curl Pro Peniche, the realistic gap was nearer to 3,000 points when you eliminated Carissa’s two low event scores (both quarterfinals) compared to Lakey’s (two ninths). 

The same rule applies heading into the season’s last event at Honolua Bay, where Carissa’s apparent 3,000-point lead is functionally closer to 1,000 points on account of the final event drop. That means if Lakey wins Honolua, she will win the Title. 

If you want the nitty gritty details on all of the above, click here

7b2fce23d86cc14335617aa146d10c6b

The way things stand, if Lakey makes the semis or beyond at Honolua, Carissa will need to tie or defeat her to win the Title. 

After learning about the Carissa points debacle, several of our commenters were shocked that the Hawaiian was effectually “losing” World Title ground due to her consistent performance throughout the season. 

Why are they dropping ANY events off the point total?” asked the Don of Yaupon. “What is the purpose of keeping track of total points if you are just going to shave a few off of everyone? They could just not mess with the points and then the person with the most points wins. Pretty simple concept.”

Replies to comment this included:

“Because you can risk something and not play safe all the time in order to not lose early. It is bad for very consistent surfers that come far but don’t ever win, but it is in favor of those that have many high results, but from time to time lose early or get injured in one or two events,” from Berritorre, and…

Takes acts of god / variables out of the equation. If Jeremy has a baby, Kelly gets insanely sick hours before his heat, JJF dry docks his sailboat on a deserted island. Well to have the odd ‘freebie’ is going to be better at determining the true champ,” from david f. 

One self-aware criticism came from 7dollarsurfboard:

Being penalized for consistency is fucked. I hope the WSL realised their shitty system is flawed. The WSL love trying their hardest to confuse us with this stupid system, the seeding round, the whole fucken Freshwater pro format etc. Dont they realise that surfers aren’t the sharpest tools in the shed.”

https://www.youtube.com/embed/Y5ckCAUVOn0

Who, us?

These were all insightful points, and they made us realize that we didn’t actually know why the WSL started this rule in the first place, or even when it came into existence for that matter. 

So, we followed the path of every great investigative team before us—some would consider Stab both the TMZ and the Bernstein and Woodward of surfing—and sent a formal information request to professional surfing’s governing body, the WSL, asking for the precise reasoning behind their oft-criticized “drop your two lowest events” rule.

Their response was shockingly to the point:

  • to accommodate for injury.
  • to accommodate for how dynamic a field of play the ocean is: swell consistency, tides, winds, slow heats, etc.

The WSL also noted that the rule has been in place since the Tour’s inception, so it’s got legacy on its side.

f6dabd0157a5861f546f4ec463eae627

Is Sally too consistent to win a Title? 

Now, we could debate the WSL’s logic until we’re sweaty and breathless, but I think the more meaningful question is: is the rule effectual?

In order to answer this question, we went back and looked at the Men’s and Women’s World Title races from 2010 to 2018 (the WSL’s publicly available data on CT seasons/events stops at 2010, hence the relatively small sample size) to discover how many potential World Champs lost a Title on account of this rule.

What did we find?

Well, over the last 18 World Title races (nine Men’s, nine Women’s), there has only been one surfer who would have been a World Champion were it not for the WSL’s “drop your two lowest event scores” rule—Sally Fitzgibbons in 2017 (Sally actually got third that year behind Tyler Wright (1) and Steph Gilmore (2)). 

In each of the other 17 races, the World Champion would have been the same person whether they kept all of their event scores or eliminated the worst two. 

5aea7345dc35a7918d5baffa6b4777d6

Can’t take his crown!

What does this tell us, beyond the fact that strong teeth do not a World Title surfer maketh?

That at the end of each year, the dominant competitor on both the Men’s and Women’s tours, wins. Also, the “drop your two lowest scores” rule does little to achieve its intended result— at least in recent history—so statistically speaking, we could probably do without it. 

However, I actually think the rule serves a clever purpose, and if it were my decision, I would choose to keep it in place. 

Sorry, Carissa/Sal!

Comments

Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up

Advertisement

Most Recent

Laird Hamilton on The Limitations of Being a Purist, Invention vs. Ownership + Why He Never Had a Sticker Deal 

Untold stories from his How Surfers Get Paid interview.

Jul 4, 2025

Surf100 Challenge Series Presented By Pacifico: Episode 3

"The tribe has spoken," Dane Reynolds pronounced, and a surfer's torch was snuffed.

Jul 3, 2025

When Surfer’s Eye Is Actually Cancer

Erin Campbell's brutal journey from surf camp dreams to chemo drops, cryotherapy, and surgical horror.

Jul 3, 2025

Surfing’s 2025 Q2 Report

An assessment of surfing's vital signs throughout the second quarter of 2025.

Jul 2, 2025

What Actually Happened to Occy’s Mad Max Plunger Pool In Yeppoon?

Surf Lakes’ brass talks: internet hecklers, the unplugging of the plunger, and the Tom Curren…

Jul 2, 2025

Poor Goofy Foots 

Data shows that the world is stacked against goofs — they even make 15% less money than…

Jul 1, 2025

Britain’s First Wavepool Has Closed — What Really Happened?

Bankruptcy, social media hackings, debts unpaid — and yet, reopening looms.

Jul 1, 2025

Watch: Was Matt Meola’s Air Actually Better Than Hughie’s?

Watch the full Swatch Nines highlight reel and decide.

Jun 30, 2025

Houshmand Bludgeons Field To Win Second CT — Molly Picklum Tastes Blood, Snatches World #1 In Brazil

You can't argue with big surfing — that's Saquarema wrapped.

Jun 29, 2025

37 Years Old And World #1 — What’s Changed For Jordy Smith?

On rediscovering decades old surfboard templates, having a personality on the CT, and why this…

Jun 27, 2025

Tom Lowe Stars in ‘Let Me Live’

The wild, improbable ascent of Britain’s best big-wave surfer.

Jun 27, 2025

Saq Wrap: Italo Celebrates Mid-Heat, Griff Drops A Freestyle, Jordy + Yago Continue BBQing 20-YOs

Top seeds sow ruin, Final 5 starts to crystallize.

Jun 27, 2025

Surf100 Challenge Series Presented By Pacifico: Episode 2

Our seven surviving surfers confront an oddly large California beach break.

Jun 26, 2025

SEOTY: The ‘Once-In-A-Decade’ Caribbean Swell That Kelly Slater Passed On

Michael Dunphy stars in Jimmicane's 'Blue Veil'

Jun 25, 2025

Who Owns Bingin? Legal Fight To Stop Demolition Begins

Eviction notices served for all businesses built on state land.

Jun 25, 2025

Tony Hawk Just Named Hughie Vaughan’s Internet-Breaking Air Because… No One Else Can

89% of our IG poll respondents claimed the 'stale fish flipper' was the best air…

Jun 25, 2025

German Surfers: AN INVESTIGATION

Truth is the light by which the world can see. 

Jun 24, 2025

“I Lost Everything I’ve Ever Owned, But This Board Came Back”

One month after the LA wildfires, a surfboard washed ashore.

Jun 24, 2025
Advertisement