Stab Magazine | What Should The WSL Do About Their Terrifying Shark Problem?

Live Now — Stab's Best Wetsuits 2025

173 Views

What Should The WSL Do About Their Terrifying Shark Problem?

With shark sightings all week, multiple attacks near the Margaret River Pro in the past 24 hours, WSL officials are left facing an existential quandary: to surf, or not to surf?

news // Apr 17, 2018
Words by stab
Reading Time: 3 minutes

Yesterday, in Gracetown, WA, there were two shark attack incidents. The first resulted in a badly injured surfer and the other produced only minor wounds.

Just around the corner from those incidents, the WSL was holding the second round of the Women’s Margaret River Pro. After the first attack, the WSL took a brief pause in competition but eventually resumed. Competition had finished for the day by the time of the second attack.

Both attacks are presumed to have been by a four-meter Great White, perhaps even the same one.  Also worth noting is the dead whale that washed up at Lefthanders, another nearby break, which could be drawing sharks into the region.

Armed with this knowledge, the WSL has a decision to make: Do they send their surfers out into potentially, nay definitely dangerous waters, in order to finish the event, or do they cut their losses and move onto the next event?

For the record, ending a WSL competition early due to a shark problem would not be unprecedented: in 2015, when Mick Fanning was hit by a White Pointer in the opening stages of the Jeffrey’s Bay final, the Commissioners’ Office rightly decided to call the event rather than chancing another encounter. 

The WSL released this message on their Instagram just minutes ago: 

Screen Shot 2018 04 16 at 2.05.02 PM

The caption reads: WSL continues to assess the current situation at the Margaret River Pro where there have been two confirmed shark incidents near Gracetown in the last 24 hours. We have actioned our well established safety protocols and are gathering all the latest information to determine next steps. We will continue to liaise with all involved, most importantly the surfers, their safety remains paramount. Today’s competition (Tuesday in Western Australia) has already been called off and all surfers have been advised not to surf in the area. We are constantly evaluating the situation, and will update as soon as possible.

This is a very difficult situation to navigate.

On one hand, the safety of the surfers should be the WSL’s primary concern.

On the other hand, the men and women of the Championship Tour risk their lives every single time they paddle out, whether in competition or not, be it to sharks, reef, or any other obstacle that could cause them to lose motor functions and drown.

So really, the surfers’ safety is never guaranteed. That’s just reality. 

At the same time, if there were crocodiles swarming all over a golf course, bears constantly intruding on baseball games, or vicious, giant prehistoric gophers on the footy field, there’s no way the PGA, MLB, or AFL would allow competition to resume. It’d just be too dangerous. 

This is especially difficult to manage in an ocean-based sport like surfing, where predators move more or less invisibly beneath the water’s surface.

I don’t care how many “safety protocols” you’ve implemented; there’s no stopping a hungry White. (Just ask John John, who was maybe almost eaten mid-wave in his Round 1 heat, and also once before the event.)

Surely the WSL knows this.

So the decision then becomes moralistic in nature: Do they risk the surfers’ lives for the sake of competition, or clicks, or whatever it is they (and we) stand to gain from this event’s completion, or do they leave with their tails between their legs but all limbs in tact?

And taking this even further, if the WSL does decide to cease competition, will they ever come back to Western Australia? What about Bells, Snapper, and J-Bay, all spots which have enjoyed large shark populations, historically?

While there’s no “right” call here, there definitely might be a wrong one. 

We wish the WSL and all of its competitors the best of luck in these coming days. 

Comments

Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up

Advertisement

Most Recent

Major Surf Brands In Turmoil As ABG Pulls North American Licenses

From pro surfers to brand fate, details emerge from an emergency meeting today in California.

Dec 11, 2024

2024 Vans Pipe Masters Day One — Live Updates, Commentary, And Conjectures

Play-by-play insights and video highlights from down on the sand.

Dec 10, 2024

The Rip Curl Eddie Aikau Waiting Period Has Officially Begun

120 days for Waimea to show her teeth.

Dec 10, 2024

Watch: Eithan Osborne in ‘Skinny Meat Head’

The Stab High Japan winner drops his profile film with Chapter 11.

Dec 10, 2024

Stab’s 2024 Super Dooper Mega Holiday Gift Guide

Everything we (actually) use and adore, for the surfer in your life.

Dec 9, 2024

The 20 Best Surfboard Models On The Market, According To You — Part 1

You told us about your favorite models, we compiled the data, and one brand massively…

Dec 8, 2024

Unlocked: Adrien Toyon in ‘North Stars’

A Film of the Year nominee from Yentl Touboul.

Dec 8, 2024

Stab Edit of the Year: Is Dane Henry The World’s Best Junior?

"It's been the best year of my surfing life," says the freshly 18yo.

Dec 6, 2024

The 2024 Vans Pipe Masters Instruction Manual

Whispers from the ground, courtesy of event director Nate Fletcher.

Dec 5, 2024

The Largest Luxury Brand In The World Just Invested In Boardbags

And one clever South African is getting a paycheck.

Dec 5, 2024

This $90k Custom Troopy Could Be Yours

Check out the Gage Roads surf team Jack Robinson, Jacob Willcox and Margo taking it…

Dec 5, 2024

Watch: Stab’s Best Wetsuits Of 2025

Who makes this season's best 3/2? We tested 24 in Canada to find out.

Dec 5, 2024

How Airplanes and Beeswax Could Change the Way Surfboards Are Made

A plausible future for eco-friendly surfboards (that isn't just flax).

Dec 3, 2024

(Unlocked) Stab Edit of the Year: Soli Bailey Stars in ‘Conehead’ 

The frontrunner for Stab Surfer of the Year 2024 drops his highly-anticipated edit shot at…

Dec 3, 2024

Stab Edit of the Year: Erwin Bliss In ‘Dipsychia’

"Nothing about those stupid influencers inspire me. They know fuck all about life."

Dec 2, 2024

Red Bull No Contest Wanders Waikiki + Crossteps Along Oahu’s South Shore

Exploring the 300,000 strong, 177.2 square mile surf cultural hub of Honolulu.

Dec 1, 2024

“We Locked Eyes For A Second, And I Was Like, ‘Here we go again’”

JOB recounts his 20-year anniversary double-barrel with Mike Stewart

Nov 30, 2024

Stab Interview: Raimana Van Bastolaer Explains His Unparalleled Surfing Career Path

From turning pro in one month, to jetskis over his head, to becoming a surf…

Nov 30, 2024
Advertisement