Stab Magazine | The WSL Is Formalizing Its Qualification Tyranny In 2020

Live Now: "Horse" — A surf film by James Kates starring Noa Deane — streaming exclusively on Stab Premium.

264 Views

The WSL Is Formalizing Its Qualification Tyranny In 2020

New year, same dictators!

news // Jan 9, 2020
Words by Stab
Reading Time: 4 minutes

Recently, the WSL announced its dissemination plan for the two “Season Wildcard” slots on the Men’s 2020 Championship Tour. 

Of the three injured surfers who applied for these wildcards, Adriano de Souza will retain full rights to one (as he is a former World Champ) while Mikey Wright and Leo Fioravanti (who are both relative newcomers to the Tour) will each compete in the first three events of the 2020 season, after which the surfer placed higher in the rankings will retain the second wildcard for the remainder of the year.

A simple, and most would say fair, plan for all surfers involved.  

But as we learned from the Medina/Ibelli/Article 171.11 dilemma at Pipe, the WSL’s MO is to preserve ultimate decision-making power in every aspect of their operation, so that they can, well… script this. 

Need proof? Stab was recently leaked an image of a message sent by the WSL to its 2020 Championship Tour surfers. You can read it here: 

Screen Shot 2020 01 07 at 10.03.53 PM

In the first episode of CUSP (recorded prior to the WSL’s decision on the Mikey/Leo situation), Stace Galbraith and I chatted about the potential 2020 wildcard outcomes, coming to the conclusion that Mikey would likely be given the second wildcard over Leo on account of the intrigue he brings to the Tour. We were, ultimately, wrong in this micro-assumption, but the broader implication of our claim was correct: the WSL will make whatever decision is best for them (they went with the three-event surf-off to appease both surfers while also creating a unique storyline around the Australian leg—genius!). 

The new wildcard rule, which will come into effect for the 2021 Championship Tour, formalizes the WSL’s tyranny around qualification.

Here are the implications: 

Eliminating the double-qualifier-beneficiaries is basically saying that if you can’t beat ’em, you can’t join ’em. Fair enough. In the past very many years, no backdoor qualifier has made a big impact in their following year on Tour, so why should the WSL give them special treatment? Either make the QS top-10 or get to the back of the line (Prove me wrong, Cibilic.) 

However, the WSL started to lose me when they talked about not (necessarily) supporting injured surfers. Mikey Wright clearly deserves to be on Tour, and a bad back (injured at one of their events, no less) shouldn’t strip him of his true Rookie year.

Plus, the WSL’s qualifying phrase “best interest of the sport” is even more subjective and vague than the “unsportsmanlike” and “of a serious nature” clauses that acquitted Medina in his clear infraction of 171.11. So, if the WSL believed the sport of surfing would benefit from having Zoltan Torkos on Tour—just kickflippin’ his way to two-point heat totals all year—could they wave their magic wand and make it so?

Methinks yes. But it doesn’t stop there.

Lest we forget that one male and one female slot for the 2021 Tour will come from Ultimate Surfer*, the WSL’s rip-off reality show that will see wannabe Tour-sters (all American, I might add) dueling in synthetic surf for the most unwarranted ascension since Trump came to office (note: that’s not a political statement, but a direct comparison of reality stars leveraging their celebrity to assume lofty titles beyond their skillset).

Just this week, Ultimate Surfer applicants were interviewed by the WSL, who will compile a personalized casting video for each surfer and present them to ABC, who will then make the final decision on which applicants appear on the show (or so we hear).

 

png ultimate surfer thumbnail 2 617x353 1024x586

Inverse Slater, a good start!

So what does all of this mean? 

From where I’m standing, it’s clear that all of these changes come back to the same, simple principle: the WSL’s competition model is commercially broken, so it’s within their best interest (and, frankly, their rights) to control the narrative and thus undam the CT revenue stream.

While this all might feel a little skeevy on the surface, if you take a second to consider the implications, it’s really not that bad.

Worst case scenario, we end up with a few quirky, vlog-centric, and otherwise inert surfers on the 2021 Tour. They’ll lose second round and we’ll hardly remember they were there, like Soli Bailey in 2019.

Best case scenario, the WSL (and ABC) will promote surfers who bring both entertainment and performance to CT, like Mason Ho, Clay Marzo, and Bethany Hamilton. We won’t miss the journey(wo)men for a second when these freaks are scalping the Medinas and Moores of the world. 

With a clear need to increase Tour-based revenue, I back the WSL’s decision to mix up their qualification process. If they want more viewers, they need to provide more entertainment. And a fresh cast of characters is a decent start.

Next step: cutting the men’s Tour in half.

*Quick question: if the WSL is saying that 10 surfers will still be coming up from the Men’s 2020 QS (assuming there are no double-qualifiers), does this mean that the Ultimate Surfer winner’s slot will come from their now-totally-autonomous “Season Wildcard”, or would they dare knock off the 22nd ranked CT surfer? Definitely the former, right?

Comments

Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up

Advertisement

Most Recent

Balaram Stack On Weed, Spirituality, Corpo Drama, Ghosting The WSL, And Making His Mom Cry

The Stab Interview with New York's beloved son of Mary.

Apr 6, 2025

Sometimes, An Incorrect Forecast Is A Good Thing

Day four in El Salvador subverts our negative expectations.

Apr 5, 2025

The Best Surfing I’ve Ever Seen: Rick Rifici

On Taj Burrow, Fair Bits, helicopters, Wolfmother, and Stab's first issue.

Apr 4, 2025

Wildcards Persist On Day Three In Surf City El Salvador

Six elimination heats in the blazing equatorial sun.

Apr 4, 2025

We’d Be Mad Too If We Surfed That “7.43” Like Filipe

Thankfully, it didn't matter at the Surf City Pro El Salvador.

Apr 4, 2025

Can A New Wetsuit Liner Save You A Mil? 

Quiksilver and Primaloft say yes — and they've got the science to back it up. 

Apr 4, 2025

The Art of Losing

Notes from the world's best runners up — because you can't win every time.

Apr 3, 2025

The Walters Brothers: Ocean & Earth’s Gen Z Gambit 

Harley on being a goof in the land of right points + riding Taj Burrow’s…

Apr 2, 2025

Wait… Wasn’t It Supposed To Be Firing Today?

Deceived by the meteorology on Day One at the Surf City El Salvador Pro.

Apr 2, 2025

Surfing’s 2025 Q1 Report 

A performance analysis of surfing’s culture, competitions, industry and more.

Apr 2, 2025

What’s Surf City El Salvador Really Like?

Your 2025 El Salvador Pro Preview, live from the cobblestones.

Apr 1, 2025

Watch: Deep Blue ft. Albee Layer, Russell Bierke, Tyler Larronde, Torrey Meister + Wilem Banks

"Wilem’s wave might be the biggest ever successfully paddled into. Aaron Gold’s 2016 El Niño…

Apr 1, 2025

Stab Exclusive: “Hail Mary” — A Balaram Stack Biopic

Featuring a bespoke soundtrack, a Pipe Masters victory, and THAT Teahupo'o session.

Mar 31, 2025

Can This Blue Collar Foamball Authority Nail The ‘Surf City’ Winner Once Again?

The 7 surfers most likely to win the El Salvador CT according to Skip McCulloch.

Mar 31, 2025

Are We Entering the Golden Age of Surf Skits?

McTavish offers a modern gem to sit alongside the greats.

Mar 30, 2025

Empty Set: How Much Do Pro Surfers Actually Know About Their Boards? 

Britt Merrick, Matt Biolos, Jake Paterson and Kanoa Igarashi weigh in.

Mar 29, 2025

How A 40-Year-Old Surf Dad Qualified For The CS Alongside His Daughter… On Twin Fins

"If you're at the party, you might as well dance." - Josh Kerr

Mar 28, 2025

Jordy Smith Wants To Be The First Surfer To Do 20 Years Straight On The CT

And more revelations from DB's new 'Pack Heavy, Chase Light' episode on Jords.

Mar 28, 2025
Advertisement