Stab Magazine | Hurricane Chaser Brett Barely Breaks Down NYC Surf Fine Fiasco

Live Now — Episode 2 Of Surf100 Challenge Series Presented By Pacifico

141 Views

Hurricane Chaser Brett Barely Breaks Down NYC Surf Fine Fiasco

“It’s so bizarre, it makes no sense whatsoever. I’m just trying to wrap my head around it.”

news // Sep 6, 2016
Words by Stab
Reading Time: 2 minutes

The home of urban haute surf couture, New York City, has hit another hurdle in its quest to become a credible surf community – the NYPD. The men and women in blue who first brought us Sipowitz have a new claim to fame as the most pedantic kooks on planet earth. The New York Police Department hit Rockaway beach on Sunday to slap several surfers with fines for surfing a four foot Hurricane-swell, generated by the offshore Tropical Storm Hermine. 

The New York Post reports at least four surfers were hit with tickets for refusing to get out of the water, costing them $80 each. One of them was 48 year old Kiwi, Jay Harrison. 

“We only get a couple of days a year for all the conditions to come together. It’s really disappointing,” he told the NYPost.

Gonzalo Brett Barley

Worth the risk of a run in with the law? Photo: Daniel Pullen

East Coast American Pro, Brett Barley, who’s made a career out of chasing hurricane swells was “baffled” by the ruling. “I think that’s crazy. I understand what they’re trying to do as far as what keeps the public safe, but if you spend enough time surfing it’s really not dangerous. Those kind of rules are made by people that don’t understand the ocean and think it’s dangerous,” he says.

Barley has chased hurricanes all along the east coast though never encountered any grief from police. “It’s the luck of the draw,” he says. “I’ve never had issues with it. I don’t know where it is they do it, I’ve been up there for hurricane swells and I do know it’s an issue for some of the counties up there, but I don’t know where exactly.”

“Those kind of rules are made by people that don’t understand the ocean and think it’s dangerous.”

Barley mightn’t have run afoul of authorities but his friends have. Fellow Hurricane-chasing pro, Alek Parker, drove hundreds of kilometres in pursuit of a storm only to be stopped by police within sight of brown spitting barrels at the end of a street in Maryland. He was fined $100 and told to turn his car around 

“All we’re doing is trying to navigate around them in a safe manner. I wouldn’t have gone around the roadblocks if I knew it was bad. I knew [the storm] had passed!” recalls Alek. 

Not to be deterred, Alek wrangled a National Geographic Press Pass, snuck through the police blockades and got the vision. “We all know we’ll do whatever it takes to get there and surf,” he says.

Comments

Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up

Advertisement

Most Recent

Poor Goofy Foots 

Data shows that the world is stacked against goofs — they even make 15% less money than…

Jul 1, 2025

Britain’s First Wavepool Has Closed — What Really Happened?

Bankruptcy, social media meltdowns, and debts unpaid — with a reopening possibly in sight.

Jul 1, 2025

Watch: Was Matt Meola’s Air Actually Better Than Hughie’s?

Watch the full Swatch Nines highlight reel and decide.

Jun 30, 2025

Houshmand Bludgeons Field To Win Second CT — Molly Picklum Tastes Blood, Snatches World #1 In Brazil

You can't argue with big surfing — that's Saquarema wrapped.

Jun 29, 2025

37 Years Old And World #1 — What’s Changed For Jordy Smith?

On rediscovering decades old surfboard templates, having a personality on the CT, and why this…

Jun 27, 2025

Tom Lowe Stars in ‘Let Me Live’

The wild, improbable ascent of Britain’s best big-wave surfer.

Jun 27, 2025

Saq Wrap: Italo Celebrates Mid-Heat, Griff Drops A Freestyle, Jordy + Yago Continue BBQing 20-YOs

Top seeds sow ruin, Final 5 starts to crystallize.

Jun 27, 2025

Surf100 Challenge Series Presented By Pacifico: Episode 2

Our seven surviving surfers confront an oddly large California beach break.

Jun 26, 2025

SEOTY: The ‘Once-In-A-Decade’ Caribbean Swell That Kelly Slater Passed On

Michael Dunphy stars in Jimmicane's 'Blue Veil'

Jun 25, 2025

Who Owns Bingin? Legal Fight To Stop Demolition Begins

Eviction notices served for all businesses built on state land.

Jun 25, 2025

Tony Hawk Just Named Hughie Vaughan’s Internet-Breaking Air Because… No One Else Can

89% of our IG poll respondents claimed the 'stale fish flipper' was the best air…

Jun 25, 2025

German Surfers: AN INVESTIGATION

Truth is the light by which the world can see. 

Jun 24, 2025

“I Lost Everything I’ve Ever Owned, But This Board Came Back”

One month after the LA wildfires, a surfboard washed ashore.

Jun 24, 2025

Shock Therapy: World 1 & 2 Eliminated Early In Saquarema

Gabriela Bryan and Caity Simmers fall victim on Day 1 of the Vivo Rio Pro.

Jun 22, 2025

German University Surf Contest Derails After Local Pushes Competitor Off Wave

The story behind the shove, and why wave-rental politics turned physical in Seignosse.

Jun 22, 2025

An Accidental 90-Minute Chat With Caity Simmers

A Stab Interview on life, individuality, and chimpanzee research initiatives.

Jun 21, 2025

No Tears In Saquarema

Can anyone other than Italo, Filipe or Yago win the Vivo Rio Pro?

Jun 20, 2025

Why Is One Of The World’s Longest Lefts Being Bulldozed?

Pavones residents displaced as excavators move in.

Jun 19, 2025
Advertisement