Stab Magazine | Deconstructing Surfing's Obsession With The Hall Of Fame

Deconstructing Surfing’s Obsession With The Hall Of Fame

There are over seven of them, including one for dogs. 

news // Jul 12, 2017
Words by stab
Reading Time: 2 minutes

“Fast Eddie is dead.” 

The text hit my phone at 7:30 this morning. Typically, chasing “surf news” is a quixotic endeavour. More often than not, it involves regurgitating press releases, inserting boilerplate quotes and towing the company line, but every once in awhile a story has the potential to stop you in your tracks. The death of Da Hui ringleader Eddie Rothman would be one such story.

A quick scan of social media and news sites and within five minutes it was pretty clear Eddie was, thankfully, still alive (and probably still causing Graham Stabelberg consternation). While grasping at threads regarding the potential untimely death of a North Shore strongman, an email landed. The title read: “Mick Fanning Enters 2017 Surfers’ Hall of Fame.”

This is exactly the type of news that “surf journalists” are supposed to psyche on. Who wouldn’t want to break the story of Fanning getting into the Hall of Fame? The problem is that this announcement was made back in April and they’re just trying to drum up more press. It’s hardly news.

The other problem is that this whole Surfers’ Hall of Fame thing is a huge farce. It’s not like getting into Cooperstown, NY for baseball players. It doesn’t have that kind of clout. There’s no criteria or selection committee. There’s no panel of experts that vote. It’s as incestuous as everything else in the surf industry.

The Surfers’ Hall of Fame is located on the corner of PCH and Main Street in the Orange County hamlet formerly known as Surf City. The “Hall” is directly in front of Huntington Surf and Sport and is chaired by HSS owner Aaron Pai—who presumably lords over the decision-making process. Directly across the street, in front of Jack’s Surf Shop, is the Surfing Walk of Fame. Every summer both shops hold competing ceremonies inducting the next class of arbitrarily selected surfers. Except Barton Lynch, he deserves his plaque!

But these are hardly the only “hall of fame” franchise in surf. There’s an East Coast Surfing Hall of Fame. There’s a New Jersey Surfing Hall of Fame. Every year Surfing Australia inducts a new class into the Australian Surfing Hall of Fame. If you’re from the islands you could aspire to be on the Hawaii Waterman Walk of Fame. And if you’re from the British Isles, perhaps you could make a case for entry into the Welsh Surfing Hall of Fame. This year South Africa got into the act with their new Surfers’ Circle Walk of Fame. Hell, the International Surfing Museum even has a Surf Dog Walk of Fame.

Anybody else getting the feeling that these things are just dorky marketing ploys?

The point is, maybe it’s time surfing laid off the whole hall of fame thing until they can figure out a way to make it more meaningful. In the press release sent out today regarding Mick’s induction into the Surfers’ Hall of Fame there isn’t even a “yeah, I’m stoked” quote from the three-time world champ. 

I’m sure Mick’s honoured—he’s too professional not to be—but he’s also made it pretty clear over the years he’s not a huge fan of Huntington Beach. The induction ceremony lands right in the middle of the waiting period for the U.S. Open. Which is probably, definitely, absolutely coincidental…


Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up


Most Recent

“Airlines Hate Me:” Bad Boy RyRy’s Guide To Surf Travel

Want to get pampered at the pointy end of the plane for free?

Aug 17, 2022


What Happens When You Borrow A Pro’s Board?

Joyride: The Shrizz from PANDA surfboards.

Aug 16, 2022


Mick Fanning Samples California’s Finest Local Produce

Mayhem at Lowers.

Aug 16, 2022

Mountains Died So You Could Surf

The value of sand.

Aug 15, 2022


UPDATE: People Are Still Surfing ‘La Jetee’ in Reunion Island

Returning to the best & sharkiest air wave in the world, as seen in Mod…

Aug 14, 2022

These Are Your Favorite (Female) Surfers

What the Stab reader survey teaches us about taste.

Aug 14, 2022


Kelly and Local Gal to Win Teahupo’o?

Local insights and a firing forecast.

Aug 13, 2022

These Are Your Favorite (Male) Surfers

Insights from the 2022 Stab Reader survey.

Aug 13, 2022


Fear And Loathing in Mainland Mex

Parker Coffin, Harry Roach, and the Roark crew embark on an authentic Oaxacan (surf) trip.

Aug 13, 2022

Tahiti Preview: The End Of The Road For 72% Of The CT

And hello there, blob of swell.

Aug 12, 2022


While Everyone Flocked To Tahiti, Kelly Stayed in Jbay

...And proceeded to rip the hell out of it on a "borrowed" 5-finned Tomo.

Aug 11, 2022


Can A GQ Cover Boy Take Out Teahupo’o?

Kauli Vaast is your incredibly handsome Tahiti trials winner.

Aug 11, 2022

Watch: Ramble On With Caity Simmers 

An action-rich tour behind the scenes of her triumphant first voyage to Oz.

Aug 11, 2022

PSA: Surf Filmers Not Welcome In Nicaragua

Cameras and drones are being seized on arrival, Stab spoke with two recent visitors.

Aug 11, 2022

Inside The Alternative Surfboard Marketing Machine 

Two of the biz's best — Matt Parker and Blake Peters — spill many beans.

Aug 10, 2022

The Tragic Parallels Between The Murder Of Ricardo Dos Santos & 8x World Jiu Jitsu Champion Leandro Lo

Two Brazilian sporting icons killed brazenly by off-duty police officers.

Aug 9, 2022

The Pick-Up, Vans US Open: In The Belly Of The Beast

Finger flips, shaping with Zion Wright, slurpees, Hawaiian takeovers, and the king of Surfline rewinds.

Aug 8, 2022

Albee Layer Discusses His Not-So-Budding Acting Career And The Upcoming Film “Sweet Adventure”

"Matt and Nora were tripping a little harder than I was just because they weren't…

Aug 8, 2022