1968 World Champion Says “The Women Should Compete Against The Men”
Fred Hemmings says you can’t be “equal but separate”.
A few months ago, the World Surf League made a revolutionary and commendable step towards closing the gender pay-gap.
The WSL announced that from 2019 onwards they would award equal pay to both men and women in all competitions they ran; in doing so, becoming the first American sporting association to grant equal pay, and consequently made headlines around the globe – which spread much further than our shallow surfing community.
Their reasons for doing so are relatively simple, lying upon the logical foundation that people deserve equal pay for equal work, regardless of their gender.
In the WSL’s interpretation, this meant that a woman who came first, second, or dead last should receive the same prize money her male counterpart does for the same placing.
Since the announcement, a few dissenters have come forward pointing out minor issues with the WSL’s decision. Most notably that there are double the male competitors, meaning that the women’s prize pool per surfer is now larger. Ironically, this prize pool argument was the one initially proposed by the WSL when queried about the pay gap back at the Ballito Pro Junior.
Fred Hemmings however believes that the issue extends beyond prize pool and competitor calculations. Instead, arguing that the WSL’s 2019 plan will not be rewarding ‘equal pay for equal work’ at all.
The 1968 World Champion, founder of the Smirnoff World Pro-Am, the first comp at Pipe, and Surfing Hall Of Fame Inductee believes that the men, of all the genders, are being hard done by in the current plan. In a recent interview with Hawaii Public Radio, Fred outlined his concerns and argued that the men and women should compete on an even playing field.
Not just the same waves, but head-to-head against one another in competition.
“What many of the men are saying now is that the women aren’t doing equal work, in other words the men have to compete in 15-foot Pipeline…and there’s only a handful of women that would do that,” Fred told Hawaiian Public Radio, “Women [will be] getting equal pay, but they’re separate.
“I think the next logical step in order to avoid this disparity is for women to compete directly against men and get rid of the gender bias in surfing contests. In other words the best women surf against the best men, they put all the money in one pot and divide it up based on placings and performance. That would truly be equal work for equal pay.
“I think many of the women could step up to the plate and be competitive against the men. Surfing should lead the way.”
Fred was then told by the presenter that a woman was right next to Kai Lenny during a recent hydrofoil paddleboard race, to which Fred responded, “that’s exactly right…it’s up to women to step up the the plate and start competing against men. [Plus] It would be double the prize money if you didn’t split it between men and women, the money would then be divided a lot more generously to the top performers within the sport.”
While Hemming’s intentions appear genuine and non-inflammatory, he then went on to compare the WSL’s proposal to the inequality between whites and african-americans in the early 1900’s.
“What was happening in the south especially is you had segregation – it was ‘separate but equal’. The racial discriminators were saying that [african-american’s had] equal rights – they can drink water, they can get a job and go to this restaurant – but they have to sit separately; they can get the bus, but they have to sit at the back, or they have to drink from the colours only water fountain.” Fred continued. “That’s the doctrine of separate but equal.
“You can’t be separate and equal. You can give out equal prize money but you’re not having equal competition.
“My favourite professional surfer is a woman [Steph Gilmore], she has the physique and the ability to ride 25-foot waves, she has the physique and ability to ride Pipeline at 12-15 feet and killer waves, both of which John John Florence does, but she doesn’t. At that level of competition surfing it’s your skill and mental abilities not your physical abilities as far as size and strength goes.
“This thing that women and aren’t as strong and big as men that’s not the relevant point in competitive surfing. Many of the top women’s surfers are as big or bigger than their male counterparts.”
So, what do you think?
Should we throw decades of biology aside and peg the guys and gals against one another Chopes next year? Should we come to the realisation systemic racism and gendered sports aren’t quite the same thing? Or should we just stop calling competitive surfing a sport altogether and realise it’s only us that give a fuck.
If we are to amalgamate the sexes though, let’s just hope Tatiana and Jesse’s love isn’t tainted when she smokes him with some backhand sass.
Lettuce know you’re thoughts below.
Has Fred Hemmings the former Republican senator taken it a step too far? Or is he just a voice of reason emerging from the haze of modern day social justice?
Post-career blues: mental illness, substance abuse and World Tour surfing.
Jed Smith explores the vortex of drugs, decadence and poor mental health plaguing pro surfing's…
Surfer Of The Year 2020: Michael Ciaramella, Selema Masekela, Ian Crane, Nathan Fletcher, And Jack Robinson
7 days down. 3 more to go.
The Bloody History of Australia’s Best Waves
Surfing and genocide collide at some of Oz’s most iconic spots.
Surfer Of The Year 2020: Griffin Colapinto, Italo Ferreira, Stace Galbraith, Connor Coffin, And Coco Ho
Day 6... Eyes are starting to hurt.... The other Intern quit.... Im all alone...
Surfer Of The Year 2020: Cam Richards, Albee Layer, Sierra Kerr, Mike February, and Damien Fahrenfort
Half way there, come see who's in the lead.
The Smoothest Snap Stall You Ever Did See
Burch, The Tudors and more of San Diego’s finest in Log Rap’s ‘Made You Look’.
Mark Mathews’ 12 Tips To Push Your Big-Wave Limits
Part 3 of 3: Mark Mathews guides us on board choice, accessories and dealing with…
When’s The Last Time You Saw A Blank Nose Move Like This?
Answer for yourself in Connor O'Leary's 'Far East'.
The Secret WSL Flight Set To Save The World Tour
World Tour surfing in 2021 hinges on a sneaky charter flight and two weeks on…
Stab Surfer Of The Year 2020: Tanner Gudauskas, Evan Geiselman, Tom Jennings, Karina Rozunko, And Caroline Marks
"When I first watched that edit, I honestly was so inspired that I rewatched it…
How To Surf Good Waves Sans Crowd
We've cracked the code in this week's edition of the Fwd.
Stab Surfer Of The Year 2020: Parker Coffin, Jimmy Wilson, Matt Meola, Steph Gilmore, And Eric Geiselman
Lark, Jimmicane, the queen, and more.
Stab in The Dark with Taj Burrow, Episode 1 of 4
Featuring 13 unmarked, Dark Arts constructed surfboards.