Stab Magazine | WSL Reveals Their Side Of The Medina/Ibelli Priority Scandal

WSL Reveals Their Side Of The Medina/Ibelli Priority Scandal

“No resurf. Caio was in the lineup first, further down the beach, and was rightfully rewarded priority.”

news // Oct 23, 2019
Words by stab
Reading Time: 2 minutes

Roughly a day and a half after Priority-Gate transpired, the WSL has finally come forward and offered an explanation. 

Via their Instagram, the WSL issued an official statement and breakdown of the Medina/Ibelli interference scandal. It went like this:

“No resurf. Caio was in the lineup first, further down the beach, and was rightfully rewarded priority. We can clearly hear the beach announcer say ‘Priority is with blue.”

The clip then cuts to the beach announcer, who says, “Caio with the first priority in blue, chasing a 9.37 for the lead.”

A whole two minutes passed from that moment to the moment that Medina got tangled up with Ibelli in a paddle-battle, leading to Medina’s interference and subsequent loss. 

The WSL then cuts to time-coded footage, which shows Medina and Ibelli paddling out simultaneously after their rides. Ibelli clearly gets past the impact zone before Medina and even sits down on his board for a moment, before deciding to head north toward the peak where Medina was settled.

That’s probably why Medina didn’t realize that Caio had priority all along.

This is what Caio’s fiancé and former CT surfer, Alessa Quizon, had to say on the matter:

“It’s unfortunate how much heat @caioibelli has already taken from this situation. I’m glad that clarity was justified on the interference. It is what it is. But what I found disappointing to me, was how some fans reacted to the call. At the end of the day both athletes are born and bred from the same country. Where I come from in Hawaii, we support our locals equally and back them 100%. one should never be pitted against the other. regardless of the situation. Caio’s been taking some unnecessary hits/ comments that no human deserves. It’s amazing to see how much passion fans have for their idols but it should come from a good place. No hate or malice. Both athletes are fighting for their dream/place on tour. The perspectives are different but both severe and equally important. Wishing all the athletes this year good vibes and positive energy from here on out. Thank you @wsl for giving us surfers the chance to make the dream happen.”

While most level-headed fans will admit that Medina was responsible for checking the priority flag, and that his failure to do so correlated directly with his demise, some remain adamant that Caio’s 3.1 score for a one-turn right should have come under the 2.78 requirement, meaning that Medina should have won the heat despite his interference. 

That is a completely different argument, and in my mind, one that holds an ocean to the priority’s puddle. However, the WSL has never been in the business of changing their scores, even when mocked, threatened, or under direct muffin fire (keep fighting, Sunny!). 

So that’s that. Medina’s tactical error has breathed new life into the 2019 World Title race, and we’re all better for it. Stay tuned for a detailed analysis of the current Title scenarios vis a vis Medina’s untimely departure. 


Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up


Most Recent

Snake’s Measured Hot Take On The Surf Ranch Imbroglio

'Cop it on the chin and move on'.

Jun 4, 2023

How John John Lost To A Surfer From Germany

The underdogs are barking: here's what's happened at the 2023 ISA World Games thus far.

Jun 3, 2023

SEOTY: This German-Born, Spanish-Speaking Ubermensch’s Clip Is For The Every-mensch

Watch Leon Glatzer make the ocean his Autobahn in "Águila".

Jun 3, 2023

Made Lana’s Special Relationship

Sunset at The Edge with Uluwatu's favourite son.

Jun 1, 2023


“We Woke Up And A Bear Had Chewed A Wetsuit To Bits”

Didn't know there were so many slabs in Canada, eh?

May 31, 2023

Britt Merrick Becomes Winningest SITD Shaper

Here's how he did it.

May 31, 2023

2023 ISA World Games Preview: Olympic Ballyhoo With 4 New Countries Competing

And why El Salvador’s President says that surfing is “one of the pillars” of the…

May 31, 2023

WSL CEO Erik Logan Responds To ‘Unfair Judging’ Claims In Open Letter

“It is a breach of league policy, for surfers to choose not to engage with…

May 30, 2023


‘Vertentes’ Is 16-Minutes Of Seamless Surfing And Self-Animated Artisanship

Time off tour has done nothing but good for Tomas Hermes.

May 30, 2023

The Man Who Tortures Surfboards For Science

Here's what Dr. Luca Oggiano and Donald Brink think surfboard manufacturers are getting wrong.

May 30, 2023

Gabriel Medina Gives Scathing Review Of WSL Judging After Controversial Surf Ranch Final

‘The surf community has been mesmerized by the poor clarity and consistency of judging for…

May 29, 2023

Griffin Colapinto And Carissa Moore Lift Lumber At Groundhog Day Rodeo

"There's so much in your control that you almost overthink things."

May 29, 2023

Surfing’s Decadent And Depraved Kentucky Derby: Day One

'It's still a wavepool comp'

May 28, 2023

Stab In The Dark With Italo Ferreira, Episode 4

And the shaper behind 2023’s best high-performance shortboard is…

May 28, 2023

Your Loss, Tahiti’s Win

Betonline.AG are donating 100% of their earnings (your losses) from Lemoore towards Tahitian flood victims.

May 26, 2023

The Surf Ranch Pro Preview: 2% Wildcards, Sudden-Death Duels, And Game Theory

Same swamp, (slightly) different rodeo.

May 26, 2023

Exclusive: Stab Speaks With El Niño 

"I’m just focusing on staying potent, moist and warm. I’m not really thinking that far…

May 25, 2023


Watch: Gabriel Medina Ping Pongs Off Brazil’s Most Exclusive Pool Coping Before Lemoore

'The waves at Boa Vista Village are so extravagant, they come with their own personal…

May 24, 2023