"This Is The Worst Judging I’ve Ever Seen" - Stab Mag

Now Live: "Zipper" — A Film By Stab & Monster

Photo: Ed Sloane/WSL

“This Is The Worst Judging I’ve Ever Seen”

Gabriel Medina sounds off after Cole Houshmand wins brute backhand battle.

news // Mar 29, 2024
Words by August Howell
Reading Time: 3 minutes

You can read our full Premium coverage of Day 3 here

“This is the worst judging I’ve ever seen. It’s bad for the sport. I’ve been through a lot of judging things. But I feel like this is the worst one. But it’s something we’ve got to talk about. We pretend it’s not happening. It’s happening and it’s bad for the sport. Hopefully, it can improve and get better, hopefully, they listen more to us.”

Those were Gabriel Medina’s choice comments to Laura Evener on the glass after watching Cole Houshmand get the highest-scoring wave on the last ride of their Round of 32 matchup. It was a close finish (Cole’s 14.27 vs Gabriel’s 13.77), but the San Clemente man gave Gabriel his third 17th-place finish in four events this season. 

Gabriel looked in rhythm to start the backhand battle. Cole kept pace with him but wasn’t quite matching the Brazilian’s speed and variety. 

Midway through the heat, Gabriel launched a full rotation backside reverse. He got inverted, but it wasn’t super high and he had to fight the whitewater on the landing. The score didn’t improve either of his top two waves as the judges gave him a 6.3. 

Was Gabe undercooked?

After Gabriel’s air, Cole started to heat up, getting a 6.8 for several sharp snaps on a wave that fizzled on the inside. He was left needing a 6.98 to get past Gab in the waning minutes of the heat.

Here’s a breakdown of the final exchange: 

With 1:52 on the clock, Gabriel sat on the shoulder with priority and the lead, watching Cole stroke into one from the outside. Gab let Cole have the wave, because it was a smaller one for the heat (which Gabriel pointed out after), but Cole unloaded the clip with five solid turns. His first one sprayed Gabriel, and he followed it up with a series of diagonal snaps. 

“It was a fun heat. Honestly, I just wanted to go out there and try to do my best surfing and have fun with it,” Cole said. Aaron Hughes/WSL

Cole finished the wave, texted a shrug emoji to the judges, and was rewarded with a 7.47, the highest score of the heat. Thanks to the WSL’s new live rankings, we know that the win helped Cole leap five spots and (for now) above the mid-year cut line at No. 21 in the world. 

In a recent @stab IG story poll, 66% of respondents thought Medina should have won the heat over Cole. This situation comes just days after a recent WSL judging mishap, where many fans believed that George Pittar was unfairly eliminated by Ethan Ewing.

Not for the first time, Gabriel called out the judging in his post-heat interview. After the Surf Ranch event last year, Gabriel took to Instagram to air his grievances with inconsistencies while “rewarding very simple surfing, seamless transitions” as opposed to variety and progression.

This instance, however, he claims is “the worst one” he’s ever been involved in.

Who do you think won? Disqus (civilly) below. 

You can read our full Premium coverage of Day 3 here


Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up


Most Recent


After 30 seasons on tour, 56 event wins & 11 world titles, Kelly Slater has…

Apr 16, 2024

Did Kelly Slater Just Retire?

3 decades, 56 event wins, and 11 World Titles later.

Apr 16, 2024

Goofies Dominate, Ewing Detonates, The GOAT Is Led To Slaughter

Once cut, twice shy.

Apr 15, 2024

The Eddie Gets A New Headline Sponsor, Coca Cola Group Stickers A 2x World Champ, The Tractor Scoops Up 2x SSOTY Winner + SITD Star Parts Ways With O’Neill

The surf industry is showing signs of life — here's a Q1 2024 update.

Apr 13, 2024

The Best Surfing I’ve Ever Seen: Duncan Macfarlane

Covid cleared the lineup while Rasta, Creed and Wade went to work.

Apr 13, 2024

The Stab Interview: Actor Jeffrey Wright

The Oscar nominee for "American Fiction" on what Hollywood can learn from surf films, why…

Apr 13, 2024

This Would Be The Best Surf Trip Of 99.9% Of Surfers’ Lives

Surfline and O'Neill manage to score untouched zones (again) + Soli Bailey adds more inertia…

Apr 12, 2024

Chippa Wilson Stars In ‘Zipper’ — A Surf Film By Stab & Monster

Featuring Filipe Toledo, Harry Bryant, Bobby Martinez, Eithan Osborne, Taro Watanabe, and Dion Agius.

Apr 11, 2024

A Big Ol’ Flaccid Salad

It was hard to be charitable about the opening day in WA.

Apr 11, 2024

Stab Interview: A Rare Glimpse Into The Mind Of World Number 2, Ethan Ewing 

On his favourite surfer (not who you'd think), high-budget surf films, and what it will…

Apr 10, 2024

Full Framey: How Soli Bailey Seized The Wave Of The Swell Event (Again)

A land angle of the backless time-warp and a firsthand encapsulation of the Tasmanian expedition.

Apr 10, 2024

Dead Reckoning: A Western Australia Margaret River Pro Preview

Can John regain his 2017/19 glory? Will Tyler and Gab make the cut?

Apr 9, 2024

There’s A Razor-Sharp Guillotine Hovering Over Two 3x World Champs in WA

Margaret River Boardriders Prez says ‘put your BOAG money on Pinto + Pickles’

Apr 9, 2024

Watch: A Cylindrical And Cinematic Approach To Stab Edit Of The Year

Conor Maguire and Clem McInerney’s ‘Hounds of the Storm’, presented by Red Bull Surfing, is…

Apr 8, 2024

This Aerospace-Inspired Board Builder Is Closing Down In Three Weeks

And not because they weren't selling.

Apr 6, 2024

Rumor: The WSL Has Chosen A New CEO

Former employee of Activision, Microsoft, Netflix, and Hulu to take surfing’s reins.

Apr 6, 2024

The Sun Is Shining On Nathan Florence, Who Just Banked A Chunk Of Equity In Surfing’s Fastest-Growing Brand

In the most difficult surf sponsorship climate in modern history, the best surfers are still…

Apr 4, 2024

How Surfers Get Paid: Season 2, Episode 3

The sexualization of women's surfing.

Apr 4, 2024