Stab Magazine | Chas Smith's ode to Brodie Carr

Chas Smith’s ode to Brodie Carr

Back in 2009, Chas Smith followed the Dream Tour as a reporter. During that time, he and Brodie Carr didn’t see eye to eye until Portugal where, like real men, they engaged in physical combat (of sorts) to settle their differences. In light of Brodie’s recent resignation from the ASP, here we revisit a story […]

Words by stab

Back in 2009, Chas Smith followed the Dream Tour as a reporter. During that time, he and Brodie Carr didn’t see eye to eye until Portugal where, like real men, they engaged in physical combat (of sorts) to settle their differences. In light of Brodie’s recent resignation from the ASP, here we revisit a story that appeared on this website two years ago…


The Vice Grip of Authority

By Chas Smith

I stumble into my hotel room drunk and in love. My right shoulder is sore. Aching. And I am in love. With a man. With a strong man. His skin is clean and his pores are tight. Tanned to the perfect hue enhanced by the baby blue t-shirts he always wears. His nails are manicured. His hair cut at a proper salon, not one of those fly by night jobs where immigrants fumble about with dull scissors.

He may have a taste for younger women but I don’t care. I love him.

His name is Brodie Carr.

Brodie Carr. Say it loud and there’s music playing. Say it soft and it’s almost like praying. Brodie Carr.

I have spent the last few weeks in Europe poking fun of Brodie Carr. I have said things about him that were meant to sting. About his inappropriate sweater selection and his poor choice of footwear. And if I could take back every single one of those barbs I would. Except the ones about his inappropriate sweater selection. And also the ones about his poor choice of footwear.

Over the course of the world tour’s European leg we had become sworn enemies. He of the evil ASP. Me of the hated Stab. He the CEO with his (well-manicured) hand so firmly around the neck of surfing. Squeezing the very lifeblood out of it. Me the writer who doesn’t know what the word “integrity” means. Or “journalistic.”

And like enemies we glared at each other from across the different event sites. At Mundaka, Supertubos, The Wall and Lagido. Dagger filled glances.

But then a striking Brit named Paul Evans suggested we arm wrestle. Settle our differences the way Sly Stallone settled his. I scoffed and figured Mr. Big Shot CEO candy-stripped Brodie Carr would be too chicken. Would be scared to dance with the devil. But he agreed.

We were to meet at the hotel Soliel Peniche bar that night. Ten PM sharp.

And so I went to the bar. Thinking he wouldn’t show. But at five minutes after ten there he was in a black leather jacket that somehow had a hood. Or maybe he was wearing a black sweatshirt underneath his leather jacket. In any case, he had a hood on and came bouncing in, like a prize-fighter. Punching the air with those (well-manicured) fists and shouting my name. CHAS SMITH! PREPARE TO MEET YOUR MAKER!

I sat my beer down, stood up and said, “Brodie Carr, I curse the day you were born.”

We stood nose to nose, staring into each other’s eyes. He is tall. I am tall. He is blonde, I am blonde. He has blue eyes. I have blue eyes. His are bluer. Neither of us flinched. I smelled his Gucci pour Homme II. He smelled my Yves St. Laurent. For men.

Then we broke. I moved behind the bar, he stayed on the customer side. And we locked right hands. Still staring. Still blonde. The bar tender became skittish. Fearful. “Please gentlemen, please no!” But this death dance was on. A crowd had gathered. Tim Fisher meekly whispered, “Get ‘em tiger.” I was hoping he was on my side. I was hoping that “tiger” was me. I needed someone. My investment banker was here, sure. She had left work early and come up to Peniche. But she is an investment banker and follows sound financial instinct. Her money was on Brodie Carr. Did I mention how broad his back is? How big his arms are?

Our hands locked like to vices. Dane Sharp checked our elbows, our positioning.

And then someone shouted, “GO!” Our muscles tensed. Neither of us giving a full burst yet. Frozen. I felt my face flush. I felt the veins bulge on my neck. I could see his veins bulge as well. We continued staring into each other’s red eyes. A bead of sweat popped on his brow. Spittle curdled in the corner of my mouth. Frozen. The gathering crowd may have been roaring. I will never know. Because as our arms pulled. As our synapses fired, I began to fall in love.

Who is this Brodie Carr, anyway? He has nice skin. His teeth are really white. He smells nice. His hand feels nice. Look at those nails. How often does he get a manicure? I bet he has good money and lives a decent life. I wonder if he has a girlfriend? If he doesn’t he probably scores loads of chicks. I wonder what works better for him, with chicks, being a CEO or being part of the ASP? I wonder if he has ever met a chick who knew what the ASP was? His Australian accent is warm. He looks really good in baby blue. It enhances his natural tan. Has the ASP really destroyed surfing? I bet not. I bet all the people who think the ASP is corporate bullshit also toke marijuana cigarettes and speak about rebellion like it is still possible. Maybe the ASP is to the far political right just like me. Maybe it is a club for well-dressed pretentious white people, like me. Why don’t I like the ASP again? Why don’t I love Brodie Carr?

And then my shoulder started to weaken. My wrist began to feel that I was arm wrestling a man who doesn’t smoke. In 30 seconds it would be over. My arm lay on the bar, defeated. Brodie let out a joyous “whoop!” slapped my back and ordered me a beer.

He asked me the next morning, “A little stiff, are ya?” And I looked deeply into his bluest eyes and said, “Yes.”


Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up


Most Recent

Board Changes, Party Boys, Olympic Clues, Mega Production Crews, And More

Notes from behind the scenes on the Championship Tour.

Apr 16, 2021

Joyride Board Test: The ACSOD Monster

What a difference a set of fins can make.

Apr 16, 2021

Ch.11 TV Disciple Josiah Amico Stars In ‘Not An Athlete’

His words, not ours.

Apr 15, 2021

How A Quik Employee Was Almost Fired For Overpaying To Get Kelly Slater On The Team

Securing arguably the greatest team in the history of surfing.

Apr 15, 2021

The Consequences of Pipeline With Mikey O’Shaughnessy

Take it from a guy who cracked his helmet on the reef.

Apr 15, 2021

11-Year-Old Performs Stab High-Worthy Airs in Waco

That mute?!

Apr 15, 2021

Some Practical Advice On Training For Surfing

Yeah, you probably don't need to do squats on a Swiss ball.

Apr 14, 2021

Watch: The World Premiere of ‘That’s Caroline’

A documentary on the abrupt rise of Caroline Marks.

Apr 14, 2021

Action Bronson Is An Animal On The Boog

Watch what many are calling the best olive oil and bodyboarding video ever made.

Apr 14, 2021

Watch: The Hypnotic Movement Of Mikey February in ‘Sonic Souvenirs’

Get lost in episode one.

Apr 14, 2021

Who Do You Think Won Stab In The Dark With Taj Burrow?

A question for those spray painting profanity on our paywall.

Apr 13, 2021

Mind Map, Kai Lenny: “Jaws Has The Biggest Ramps You Could Ever Want”

This man thinks on an entirely different level.

Apr 13, 2021

Latin Americans Have an Undeniable Affinity for the Tube

Directional ambidexterity can be quite fun.

Apr 13, 2021

Did We Just See The Best Performance Since John John At Margaret River In 2017?

What the data says about Newcastle.

Apr 12, 2021

Stab Podcast: Will Italo’s Airs Be Relevant in 10 Years?

Let's discuss, on Stab CUSP.

Apr 12, 2021

Micky Clarke Moves With Disciplined Aggression

Emo Micky finds an outlet on CH 11 TV.

Apr 11, 2021

Click or Miss: Is Vlogging Harder Than It Looks?

Click or Miss Vol 23.

Apr 11, 2021

The End Of The Dark Ages On Reunion Island

After fifteen years of chaos, shark attacks, and surf bans, a recently-launched project looks to…

Apr 11, 2021