Stab Magazine | Kelly Slater Was Robbed By The WSL
628 Views

Kelly Slater Was Robbed By The WSL

The rulebook confirms, Gabby’s now-famous drop-in was not so legal after all. 

Words by stab

Surf fans were wrong about Slater’s infamous 4.17 at the 2015 Hurley Lowers Pro. So wrong that it made my brain hurt. You screamed like lunatics about an incompetent and backward-thinking judging panel, while failing to recognize falling down on your stomach and popping back up again constitute a “make” in our sport. The WSL scored it correctly, which made me very glad that surfing was a dictatorship, and not a democracy, on that day. 

But this time dear surf fans, your base instincts were correct. 

When we watched Gabriel Medina look back once, and then once more, before free-falling within feet of Kelly Slater’s head, our initial surfer response was: What the fuck?

https://www.youtube.com/embed/atZiUvv02N4

For reasons you’ll soon understand, it was more justified when Kelly did it to Joel in 2012.

As if the drop-in wasn’t bad enough, Gabby then steered his board in the opposite direction of the wave just to ensure that Kelly would receive an interference. Despite the World Title on the line, this act went beyond most surfers’ sense of competitive gamesmanship. And the message boards went crazy. 

Here are some of the tamest rinsings:

From Coconut bombs: Karma, lost your heat against Jeremy haha. Good for you medina.

From Paul D.: Media may have won the heat but he lost all of my respect (yeah I get it I’m just a fan). Kelly is already injured, and to drop in on someone in a backdoor tube is just reckless endangerment. He’s a kid dropping in on a 7 time pipe master and greatest of all time. Show some respect.

From Haha: Wrong, fucked up a wave that he had no intent of riding… if he went to ride and to get a score, fair enough…

During the live broadcast, Ronnie Blakey made a similar observation to Haha‘s. While bickering with Peter Mel about the incident, Ron Dawg said: “But there’s also another rule, right? And that is when you’ve got priority, you can’t sit down the line and take off on the wave on someone and… basically block the ride.”

While that was being explained, the WSL displayed the following visual: 

Screen Shot 2017 12 20 at 5.39.27 PM

The mixed messaging made it difficult for viewers to pinpoint who, if anybody, was in the wrong in this situation. Morality and righteousness aside, what did the rules dictate? 

If I’m being completely transparent, I believed that due to the power of Priority, Gabby was free to do what he did. If anything, based on the WSL’s policies, I thought Kelly could be at risk of an interference. A lot of viewers felt differently, but I wrote that off as the same type of emotion-based, Kelly-worshipping logic that had you believing a botched air was worth of a 10. Today I became privy to new information that has changed my view entirely. 

A few hours ago, @kellyslater posted the following on his Instagram Story, of all places:

Screen Shot 2017 12 20 at 6.22.47 PM

Did he just game the system?

And it does seem that Gabby’s offense fits perfectly within the guidelines of Rule 154:09, AKA Unsportsmanlike Interference, specifically because he turned toward Kelly as opposed to following the wave’s true direction (right). This was not only a petty move on Medina’s part, but technically it should have been an interference against Kelly. 

And how would that have played out, if it were called? Well, assuming it would have been deemed a Priority Interference, Gabs would have lost his second highest score of the heat. That would have left Gab with just one score — a 9.07 — which would have been just shy of Kelly’s two wave total of 9.16. In other words, Kelly Slater should have technically won that heat.

Not that it really matters, because Jeremy beat Gabriel in the next heat thus securing the Title for Two Johns, but it’s still pretty interesting — especially considering the uproar the incident caused in the broader surfing community.

So congrats surf fans! Your instincts were correct, and the WSL needs to take a closer look at its own rule book. 

 

 

 

Comments

Comments are a Stab Premium feature. Gotta join to talk shop.

Already a member? Sign In

Want to join? Sign Up

Advertisement

Most Recent

Joyride Board Test: The Haydenshapes Hypto Krypto Twin

Critically examining one of the hottest new boards on the market.

Oct 20, 2021

How An American’s Entrepreneurial Spirit Built One The Greatest Surf Accessory Labels Out Of A Workshop In Yallingup, Western Australia

Mick, Steph, & Jake Paterson tell the story of Creatures founder, John Malloy.

Oct 20, 2021

Why We’ll Always Catch One Down The Beach

The Misc: To the left of the stand.

Oct 20, 2021

The Highest & Flyest Performance-Based Challenges From Stab Highway Presented By Monster Energy

Rinse off the hangover and shoot for the sky.

Oct 19, 2021

3:30

Lower Trestles From Unusual Angles Ft. Kolohe, Griffin, And Co.

So much for Stagnant Ambition.

Oct 19, 2021

Are Surfboards Made To Fail?

Industry insiders open up about whether or not boards are intentionally fragile, thus driving repeat…

Oct 18, 2021

1:49

A 14-Year-Old Ladybird Takes On Solid Nias & Desert Point

Bela Nalu will go.

Oct 18, 2021

Premium Peek: Torrey Meister Tempts Fate In ‘Grit n Water’

What's scarier — bull riding or big wave surfing?

Oct 17, 2021

8:22

Someone Sponsor This Kid

Eimeo Czermak is an animal who consistently delivers jaw-dropping clips.

Oct 17, 2021

11:36

Palatable Portuguese Wedges With Mason Ho

Washed down with a pink cosmo and Franchesinha.

Oct 16, 2021

Did You Know The WSL Has A Pension Fund?

CT surfers post-2014 have a nice chunk of cash waiting for them after they retire.

Oct 16, 2021

Stab Podcast: Is Huntington Beach A More Exciting Contest Venue Than Ericeira?

Surf sins, a rundown of this week’s surf cinema, and an unpopular opinion from the…

Oct 15, 2021

The WSL’s 2022 Season Wildcards Revealed

Pray for Matthew McGillivray.

Oct 15, 2021

16:47

Dylan Graves Explores The Topics Of Race And Inclusivity In Surfing

“If you know it’s wrong, say something.”

Oct 15, 2021

Watch: Episode 2 of Stab Highway Presented By Monster Energy

Broken bones, KFC/meat pie collabs, 'feary' river mouth swims, and incredible kneelo tubes.

Oct 15, 2021

2:20

Kolohe Andino Is Doubling Down On Surf Films

"I want to give the world my view of how surfing should be perceived."

Oct 14, 2021

5:12

Jordy Smith Was Stuck In Hawaii For The Best Late-Season Run In Memory

"It was 6-8 foot for weeks straight. I surfed Pipe with one other guy out."

Oct 14, 2021

What Happened To All The Surf Gangs?

Times have changed, for good or ill.

Oct 14, 2021
Advertisement